Defining a positive work environment for hospital healthcare professionals: A Delphi study

Abstract

Introduction The work environment of healthcare professionals is important for good patient care and is receiving increasing attention in scientific research. A clear and unambiguous understanding of a positive work environment, as perceived by healthcare professionals, is crucial for gaining systematic objective insights into the work environment. The aim of this study was to gain consensus on the concept of a positive work environment in the hospital. Methods This was a three-round Delphi study to establish consensus on what defines a positive work environment. A literature review and 17 semi-structured interviews with experts (transcribed and analyzed by open and thematic coding) were used to generate items for the Delphi study. Results The literature review revealed 228 aspects that were clustered into 48 work environment elements, 38 of which were mentioned in the interviews also. After three Delphi rounds, 36 elements were regarded as belonging to a positive work environment in the hospital. Discussion The work environment is a broad concept with several perspectives. Although all 36 elements are considered important for a positive work environment, they have different perspectives. Mapping the included elements revealed that no one work environment measurement tool includes all the elements. Conclusion We identified 36 elements that are important for a positive work environment. This knowledge can be used to select the right measurement tool or to develop interventions for improving the work environment. However, the different perspectives of the work environment should be considered.

Defining adequacy of staffing in general hospital wards: a Delphi study

“…Those suggestions do not directly reflect adequacy of staffing. Staffing adequacy is one of multiple elements of a positive work environment and is essential for good patient care and nurse satisfaction 55. The work environment also influences how well nurses deal with understaffing,31 which has an indirect effect on nurses’ opinions on staffing adequacy 29…”

Nurse Leadership Development: A Qualitative Study of the Dutch Excellent Care Program

“…Two researchers (EdK and KJ or PB) held the frst three interviews, which allowed us to evaluate the interview process, the role of the interviewer, and the interview guide. Te results provided guidance for further data collection and Te Excellent Care Program is a model comprising three pillars (Figure 1): Each pillar addresses a number of aspects important to a positive nurses' work environment (Figure 1) [14,40]. All pillars can be measured by a validated questionnaire [60][61][62][63].…”

“…healthy, supportive, and stimulating). A positive work environment is defned as the inner setting of the organization in which employees work and is the result of respect and trust between employees at all levels, getting recognition for good work, getting support from management, efective collaboration and communication, a safe climate, and a healthy workplace [13,14]. Although several studies have measured the nurses' work environment [15], research is sparse on how nurses not in designated leadership positions can infuence their environment.…”

“…Nurse leadership appears crucial to creating a positive work environment [5][6][7][8]14]. According to Wei et al [8], leadership and the work environment are interdependent.…”

Acts of attrition: The pressure on our clinical pharmacists

“…Positive work environments are critical for good patient care and even retaining healthcare professionals. A three‐round Delphi study to establish consensus on a positive work environment for healthcare professionals identified 36 elements of a positive work environment with those most frequently addressed: supportive manager, leadership, supportive coworkers, and teamwork 11 . An excellent example of this has been amplified during the pandemic and the expanded work from home (WFH) opportunities.…”