Deforestation by Afforestation: Land Use Change in the Coastal Range of Chile

Abstract

In southern Chile, an establishment of a plantation-based forest industry occurred early in the industrial era. Forest companies claim that plantations were established on eroded lands. However, the plantation industry is under suspicion to have expanded its activities by clearing near-natural forests since the early 1970s. This paper uses a methodologically complex classification approach from own previously published research to elucidate land use dynamics in southern Chile. It uses spatial data (extended morphological profiles) in addition to spectral data from historical Landsat imagery, which are fusioned by kernel composition and then classified in a multiple classifier system (based on support, import and relevance vector machines). In a large study area (~67,000 km2), land use change is investigated in a narrow time frame (five-year steps from 1975 to 2010) in a two-way (prospective and retrospective) analysis. The results are discussed synoptically with other results on Chile. Two conclusions can be drawn for the coastal range. Near-natural forests have always been felled primarily in favor of the plantation industry. Vice versa, industrial plantations have always been primarily established on sites, that were formerly forest covered. This refutes the claim that Chilean plantations were established primarily to restore eroded lands; also known as badlands. The article further shows that Chile is not an isolated case of deforestation by afforestation, which has occurred in other countries alike. Based on the findings, it raises the question of the extent to which the Chilean example could be replicated in other countries through afforestation by market economy and climate change mitigation.

Unraveling the Differences in Landcover Patterns in High Mountains and Low Mountain Environments within the Valdivian Temperate Rainforest Biome in Chile

“…New datasets including large-scale (national, continental, and global) confirm the importance of forestry in Chile, and differentiation between low and high mountains is highly relevant for explaining human-induced land cover change. Our findings coincides with the results reported by Braun 2022 [52] investigating the process of land cover change in the coastal mountains between the Maule and Bío-Bío region, which are mainly low mountains. In these areas the transition towards managed forests has in nearly all areas been at the cost of primary forests since 1975 (Figure 4, Table 2).…”

Envisioning better forest transitions: A review of recent forest transition scholarship

“…However, some policies have had the unfortunate impact of displacing natural forests, either with crops or planted trees [ 40 ]. Loss of natural forests was attributed to weak governance for four cases of forest loss.…”