Delineating Geographical Regions with Networks of Human Interactions in an Extensive Set of Countries

Abstract

Large-scale networks of human interaction, in particular country-wide telephone call networks, can be used to redraw geographical maps by applying algorithms of topological community detection. The geographic projections of the emerging areas in a few recent studies on single regions have been suggested to share two distinct properties: first, they are cohesive, and second, they tend to closely follow socio-economic boundaries and are similar to existing political regions in size and number. Here we use an extended set of countries and clustering indices to quantify overlaps, providing ample additional evidence for these observations using phone data from countries of various scales across Europe, Asia, and Africa: France, the UK, Italy, Belgium, Portugal, Saudi Arabia, and Ivory Coast. In our analysis we use the known approach of partitioning country-wide networks, and an additional iterative partitioning of each of the first level communities into sub-communities, revealing that cohesiveness and matching of official regions can also be observed on a second level if spatial resolution of the data is high enough. The method has possible policy implications on the definition of the borderlines and sizes of administrative regions.

Exploring Multi-Scale Spatiotemporal Twitter User Mobility Patterns with a Visual-Analytics Approach

“…Such a dataset can cover relatively large spatial scale [23,24] (e.g., national level) and a large portion of the population in the study region [10]. However, due to the concerns of infringement on individual privacy, mobile phone call data are not publicly accessible at all.…”

Portraying Temporal Dynamics of Urban Spatial Divisions with Mobile Phone Positioning Data: A Complex Network Approach

“…National administrative boundaries have been analyzed and validated by comparing the existing specifications with community structures from interaction-based networks [11,36]. Comparative analysis on the interaction-based urban structure with different countries has been conducted as well [12].…”

How Big Data Fast Tracked Human Mobility Research and the Lessons for Animal Movement Ecology

“…At a larger spatial scale (100s of km), the extent to which human activity patterns correspond to administrative boundaries has been examined by applying algorithms of topological community detection to country-wide telephone call networks (Sobolevsky et al, 2013) and patterns in the circulation of bank notes (Thiemann et al, 2010). These studies typically report poor matches between administrative boundaries and actual geographic boundaries calculated from human mobility data.…”