This study was conducted in controlled environmental conditions to systematically evaluate multi-traits responses of winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) genotypes to different salinity levels. Responses were assessed at the germination to early seedling stage (Experiment 1). Seeds of different genotypes (n=292) were subjected to three salinity levels (0 [control], 60, and 120 mM NaCl). Principal Component Analysis (PCA) revealed that among studied traits seedling vigor index (SVI) contributed more towards the diverse response of genotypes to salinity stress. Based on SVI, eight contrasting genotypes assumed to be tolerant (Gage, Guymon, MTS0531, and Tascosa) and susceptible (CO04W320, Carson, TX04M410211) were selected for further physio-biochemical evaluation at the booting stage (Experiment 2) and to monitor grain yield. Higher level of salinity (120 mM NaCl) exposure at the booting stage increased thylakoid membrane damage, lipid peroxidation, sugars, proline, and protein while decreasing photosynthesis, chlorophyll index, starch, and grain yield. Based on grain yield, the assumed magnitude of the genotypic response shown in Experiment 1 was not analogous in Experiment 2. This indicates the necessity of individual screening of genotypes at different sensitive growth stages for identifying true salinity-tolerant and susceptible genotypes at a particular growth stage. However, based on higher grain yield and its least percentage reduction under higher salinity, Guymon and TX04M410211 were identified as tolerant, and Gage and CO04W320 as susceptible at the booting stage, and their biparental population can be used to identify genomic regions for booting stage-specific salinity response.