Distress During the COVID-19 Pandemic Among Local Public Health Workers in New York State

Abstract

Objective: Understanding the challenges public health workers have faced is critical to reinforcing, revitalizing, and strengthening the public health workforce. We measured and identified the level and causes of psychological distress among public health workers during the COVID-19 pandemic in New York State. Methods: We used a knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors survey to ask public health workers at local health departments about their experiences working in public health during the pandemic, including questions relating to harassment from the public, workload, and work/life balance. We used the Kessler-6 scale to measure participants’ psychological distress using a 5-point Likert scale, with higher scores indicating greater psychological distress. We calculated descriptive statistics and conducted a regression analysis to determine the factors associated with public health worker psychological distress, and we coded open-ended comments for qualitative analysis. Results: During September 7-20, 2021, 231 public health workers from 38 local health departments completed the survey. Respondents were predominantly non-Hispanic White (89.6%), female (82.1%), full-time employees (95.1%), and located in Upstate New York. On a bivariate level, the strongest predictor of distress was job satisfaction (–0.388), followed closely by COVID-19 fatigue (0.386) and feeling bullied or harassed by the public (0.331). In the regression analysis, 2 additional factors were associated with distress: considering leaving their job due to the pandemic and concerns about exposure. Themes from the qualitative analysis strongly supported these findings. Conclusions: Understanding the challenges public health workers have faced during the pandemic is critical to inform the actions needed—stronger state laws protecting against harassment, workforce incentives, and commensurate funding—to reinforce and revitalize our frontline public health workforce.

Teamwork and Collaboration: Bright Spots of Governmental Public Health Employee Reflections on the COVID-19 Response

“…Another highlight of this study is that respondents expressed pride in their coworker's and team's collective efforts and appreciation for the ability to serve the public. Despite much research stressing high rates of burnout and fatigue within the public health workforce,16-20 findings from this study suggest that positive internal teamwork helped offset these feelings. By supporting coworkers in their respective tasks, seeing work delegated and shared, and rallying around a common goal, many employees were motivated and expressed pride in their agency's response efforts.…”

Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the State Enteric Disease Public Health Workforce in the Western United States, March-April 2022

“…This excessive workload was said to impact mental health, leading to burnout and attrition, a consistent experience across the public health sector. 3,[12][13][14][15] Importantly, some teams reported the permanent loss of more experienced enteric disease staff members, resulting in a decrease in expertise and knowledge of past outbreaks that are often critical to the timely response to outbreak investigations. The loss of experienced staff during the pandemic, coupled with prolonged COVID-19 pandemic response deployments and recruitment challenges, means that many of the state-level enteric disease teams were less experienced than they were prepandemic.…”

Teachers’ Distress Amid COVID-19: Examining the Effects of Job Satisfaction and Efficacy, Confidence in Protective Behaviors, and Virus Anxiety

“…26,27 Similarly, workers in public health experienced extreme distress as a result of relaying health information and government mandates to an often-skeptical and even aggressive members of the public. 28 Distress was often mitigated by a supportive social network, both among college students 29,30,31 and for those living in marginalized communities. 32,33 Perhaps virus anxiety can be mitigated by a supportive social network-another important question for future research.…”