Do Meditation, Mindfulness, and Self-Compassion Impact Utilitarian Moral Judgment?

Abstract

Objectives Meditation practices, mindfulness, and self-compassion have been found to affect our physical and mental well-being in many ways. However, can they also affect our moral judgment, for example, what we think about right and wrong? This study aims to explore the potential influence of meditation, mindfulness and self-compassion on utilitarian moral judgments. Method In Study 1 (n = 316), we measured participants’ frequency of meditation, their level of mindfulness, self-compassion, and their utilitarian moral judgment through two well-known moral dilemmas (switch and bridge) and using a two-dimensional model of moral psychology (the Oxford Utilitarianism Scale with negative, i.e., instrumental harm, and positive, i.e., impartial beneficence dimensions). In Study 2 (n = 41), we conducted a psychological 8-week mindfulness course and measured the same variables as in Study 1 before and after the course. Results In Study 1, we observed that participants who meditated more often exhibited lower levels of instrumental harm. In Study 2, we found that participants had a lower level of impartial beneficence after the 8-week mindfulness course. Conclusions Practices such as meditation may be related to moral judgment, specifically to lower acceptance of harming others (instrumental harm), but they may also reduce the concern for the welfare of as many people as possible (impartial beneficence). Further research is needed to understand better if and how moral judgments may change when people meditate and develop their mindfulness and self-compassion. Preregistration The studies were not pre-registered.

The Relationship among Internet Addiction, Moral Potency, Mindfulness, and Psychological Capital

“…The results suggested that as the university classification improved, MI, psychological resources, and MP increased, while IA decreased. These findings align with previous research, indicating that sociodemographic factors, such as university classification, significantly affect the well-being of university students [ 8 , 15 , 69 ]. However, it is worth noting that the literature presents inconsistent findings, emphasizing the need for further research to gain a more comprehensive understanding of these relationships and differences.…”

The Oxford Utilitarianism Scale: Psychometric properties of a French adaptation (OUS-Fr)

“…If these results seem to demonstrate consistent construct validity of the OUS, other findings may raise questions regarding the complementarity of these two dimensions. While a number of studies have shown a positive correlation between the OUS-IB and OUS-IH scores (e.g., Kahane et al, 2018, study 2;Paruzel-Czachura & Kocur, 2023;Park et al, 2023;Navajas et al, 2021), others did not find a significant correlation between them (Filiz & Hasan, 2021;Kahane et al, 2018, study 1). Such results could mean that the two dimensions are related but distinct constructs, and play different roles in the influence of moral judgment.…”

To behave or not (un)ethically? The meditative effect of mindfulness on statistics anxiety and academic dishonesty moderated by risk aversion

“…The literature states that practising mindfulness helps improve reflection and understanding of emotions and mental events and leads to a higher capacity for objectivity regarding personal experiences (Eidman et al 2022). Additionally, research suggests that meditation influences peoples' morality (Feruglio et al 2022;Paruzel-Czachura & Kocur 2023), though with mixed results (Du et al 2023;Reynolds et al 2023).…”