Do Multinational Enterprises Relocate Employment to Low-Wage Regions? Evidence from European Multinationals

Abstract

This paper analyses the employment behavior of multinational enterprises (MNEs) in Europe.To this end we use a unique firm level panel data set of more than 1,000 European multinational parent enterprises and their affiliates. The affiliates are located either in the European Union divided into (North, South), Central and Eastern Europe or both.We find that for parent firms operating in the manufacturing sector the elasticity of parent employment with respect to North EU affiliates' labour costs is positive and statistically significant, ranging from 0.03 to 0.08, depending on the specification considered. This implies employment substitution between parents and their North EU based affiliates takes place in response to wage cost differentials between the parent and its North EU based affiliates. This substitution effect becomes stronger when affiliates are operating in a different sector than their parent firm.However, we find no evidence for such substitution effects between parent employment and its affiliates that are located in low wage regions in the EU and in Central and Eastern Europe.Furthermore, substitution effects are absent for parent firms operating in the non-manufacturing sector.Our results suggest that on average during the period of this study competition from low wage countries in Central and Eastern Europe and the South of the EU did not contribute to a relocation of domestic jobs to these low wage regions. JEL classification:F23, J23

How does investing in cheap labour countries affect performance at home? Firm-level evidence from France and Italy

“…Several earlier empirical works have examined the effects of outward FDI on output (Blonigen, 2001;Head and Ries, 2001;Desai et al, 2005), home employment (Blomström et al, 1997;Riker, 1997a and1997b;Lipsey, 1999;Bruno and Falzoni, 2000;Braconier and Ekholm, 2002;Hanson et al, 2003;Marin, 2004;Becker et al, 2005;Konigs and Murphy, 2006), productivity (Braconier et al, 2001;van Pottelsberghe de la Potterie and Lichtenberg, 2001). They generally find that the effect of FDI is positive or that short term costs get offset in the longer term.…”

An Analysis of Bookkeeping Practises of Micro-Entrepreneurs in the Retail Clothing Industry in Cape Town, South Africa

“…The employees' remuneration is recorded on payroll account. The payroll account records include both salaries and wages, of which salaries are based on monthly or yearly-basis monetary rewards, while wages are monetary rewards based on hourly rates usually paid on a weekly basis [33,35,38,51,52]. A micro-enterprise's payroll will comprise both the owner of the business' monetary reward together with the salaries/wages of employees [27,33,52].…”

Multinational versus National Firms on Capital Adjustment Costs: A Structural Approach

“…Lipsey and Weiss 1984;Blomström et al 1997;Belderbos and Sleuwaegen 1998;Head and Ries 2001;Hanson et al 2005), the consequences of multinational activity for domestic wages and employment (e.g. Feenstra and Hanson 1996;Slaughter 2000;Head and Ries 2002;Budd et al 2005;Konings and Murphy 2006;Barba Navaretti et al 2003), and (technology) spillovers from foreign direct investments (e.g. Aitken et al 1997;Haskell et al 2007).…”