Do vaccines cause epilepsy? Review of cases in the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program

Abstract

ObjectiveThe National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986 created the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP), a no‐fault alternative to the traditional tort system. Since 1988, the total compensation paid exceeds $5 billion. While epilepsy is one of the leading reasons for filing a claim, there has been no review of the process and validity of the legal outcomes given current medical information. The objectives were to review the evolution of the VICP program in regard to vaccine‐related epilepsy and assess the rationale behind decisions made by the court.MethodsPublicly available cases involving epilepsy claims in the VICP were searched through Westlaw and the United States Court of Federal Claims websites. All published reports were reviewed for petitioner's theories supporting vaccine‐induced epilepsy, respondent's counterarguments, the final decision regarding compensation and the rationale underlying these decisions. The primary goal was to determine which factors went into decisions regarding whether vaccines caused epilepsy.ResultsSince the first epilepsy case in 1989, there have been many changes in the program including the removal of residual seizure disorder as a vaccine‐related injury, publication of the Althen prongs, release of the acellular form of pertussis, and recognition that in genetic conditions the underlying genetic abnormality rather than the immunization causes epilepsy. We identified 532 unique cases with epilepsy: 105 with infantile spasms and 427 with epilepsy without infantile spasms. The petitioners’ experts often espoused outdated, erroneous causation theories that lacked an acceptable medical or scientific foundation and were frequently criticized by the court.SignificanceDespite the lack of epidemiological or mechanistic evidence indicating that childhood vaccines covered by the VICP result in or aggravate epilepsy, these cases continue to be adjudicated. After 35 years of intense litigation, it is time to reconsider whether epilepsy should continue to be a compensable vaccine‐induced injury.