Does Inter‐jurisdictional Competition Engender a “Race to the Bottom”? A Meta‐Regression Analysis

Abstract

A growing literature documents the existence of strategic political reactions to public expenditure between rival jurisdictions. These interactions can potentially create a downward expenditure spiral ("race to the bottom") or a rising expenditure spiral ("race to the top"). However, in the course of identifying the existence of such interactions and ascertaining their underlying triggers, the empirical evidence has produced markedly heterogeneous findings. Most of this heterogeneity can be traced back to study design and institutional differences. This article contributes to the literature by applying meta-regression analysis to quantify the magnitude of strategic inter-jurisdictional expenditure interactions, controlling for study, and institutional characteristics. We find several robust results beyond confirming that jurisdictions do engage in strategic expenditure interactions, namely that strategic interactions: (i) are weakening over time, (ii) are stronger among municipalities than among higher levels of government, and (iii) appear to be more influenced from tax competition than yardstick competition, with capital controls and fiscal decentralization shaping the magnitude of fiscal interactions.

The Power of Bias in Economics Research

“…[66] (2734) Stock market efficiency [79] (1719) Marriage wage premium [36] (661) ICT [115] (415) Health [9,13,[91][92]112] (169) Okun's law [101] (264) Inter-jurisdictional competition [32][33] (640) Regulation [95] (93) Institutions [5,50,53,85] (857) Ultimatum game [117] (97) Public capital productivity…”

The National Health Service at a Critical Moment: when Brexit means Hectic

“…It might prevent or reduce a hypothetical future 'race to the bottom' (a reduction in health entitlements from cross-country health system competition) in health care services if it ever developed. However, so far evidence of such a race to the bottom has not been substantiated (Costa-Font et al, 2015). Furthermore, given that health care is a devolved responsibility in the UK, it is likely that it will exhibit different effects in different countries of the UK, and especially in Scotland and Northern Ireland if they remain part of the UK.…”

Decentralized Environmental Regulation in a Model with Increasing-Returns-to-Scale

“…Production requires perfectly mobile capital inputs, Ki, the regional fixed factor, Li, and allowed pollution emissions, Ei, which are treated as an input to production akin to Oates and Schwab (1988). 3 The fixed capital stock, K , is owned in equal regional shares, ηi, by residents. 4 In this devolved environmental regulation milieu, local authorities set a standard for regional environmental quality.…”