Economic evaluation of Miscanthus production – A review

Abstract

a b s t r a c tThis paper reviews the peer-reviewed literature dealing with the economics of Miscanthus cultivation, to identify factors influencing the adoption of Miscanthus and to reveal shortcomings in research. In total, 51 studies have been identified for this review. The majority of these publications are recent (i.e. the majority is published after 2009) and concern case studies in Europe (particularly the UK and Ireland) and North America. This review reveals that the economic viability of Miscanthus depends on largely uncertain assumptions especially concerning yields (10-48 t dry matter per ha) and prices (48-134 €/t dry matter) but also concerning the lifespan (10-20 years) and different cost items. A lack of established markets, high establishment costs and uncertainties, arising to a large extent from the long term commitment, are identified as major barriers to Miscanthus adoption. In addition, the level of support for Miscanthus production (e.g. via subsidies) is identified as crucial for Miscanthus profitability, but is found to be highly heterogeneous across countries. Next to diversity in agronomic and economic assumptions, also the assessment criteria and research techniques used to investigate the profitability of Miscanthus differ widely. While the net present value criterion was most frequently used, we identify a lack of approaches that account for risks and uncertainties, which seem to potentially play a critical role in the uptake of Miscanthus by farmers.

Future competitive bioenergy technologies in the German heat sector: Findings from an economic optimization approach

“…So why does Miscanthus play only a minor role in agriculture today? Witzel and Finger [47] identify several major barriers, e.g. a lack of established markets, high establishment costs as well as uncertainties, arising to a large extent from the necessary long term commitment.…”

The costs of sugar production from different feedstocks and processing technologies

“…The fixed capital investment and the operating costs related to raw materials, utilities, and various process schemes (e.g. inclusion of recycling or heat regeneration loops) are the basic parameters used to estimate the profitability of a biorefinery process . This has led to the marketing of new technologies to increase process efficiency.…”

“…inclusion of recycling or heat regeneration loops) are the basic parameters used to estimate the profitability of a biorefinery process. 5,12,13 This has led to the marketing of new technologies to increase process efficiency. However, the economic analysis of sugar production in biorefinery processing is generally considered within the context of biofuel production and only lists the final costs of producing the biofuel and co-products.…”

Relative Greenhouse Gas Abatement Cost Competitiveness of Biofuels in Germany

“…A common methodology for estimating the costs of energy crops is to add the per hectare profit of a benchmark crop to the per hectare production cost of the energy crop(s) [62]. This opportunity cost also serves as the shadow price of land, whereas published land rents may rather be seen as marginal land rents [63].…”