Een G1000 gun je iedereen1

Abstract

A G1000 is meant for everybody: Participation in Kruiskamp, Amersfoort, the NetherlandsIn the Netherlands, citizens’ summits are employed to provide citizens a space within the present democratic system. By using a micro lens to study processes at a G1000 in a neighbourhood in the Dutch city of Amersfoort, we have gained insights into the course of the programme of the summit. We analysed how deliberation, group dynamics and (differing) mind-sets affect communication, the creation of a common ground, and the activation of citizens. We found that a safe space is required to enable participants to think out of the box during deliberation. Facilitation by skilled moderators as well as transparency during the program are seen as preconditions for a powerful operation. We also found that interference by representatives of the system world ‐ like (local) government officials ‐ can disturb the group process based on everyday life principles. Finally, this paper shows that diversity among participants is not easily reached, if at all. While the aim is to welcome everyone, there are some implicit values that especially attract the white middleclass. This makes inclusivity of different social classes, ethnic backgrounds, religions, and age a challenge that is still difficult to accomplish.

Deliberatieve democratie: ervaringen met diversiteit in burgertop Amsterdam

“…De praktijk laat zien dat het bereiken van diversiteit bij burgertoppen niet altijd makkelijk is. Zoals uit eerdere onderzoeken is gebleken (onder andere Michels & Binnema, 2015, 2016Smets & Vlind, 2015), worden burgertoppen vooral bezocht door 'witte' hoogopgeleide mensen van middelbare leeftijd en ouder. Smets en Vlind (2015) gaven aan over de wijk-G1000 in de Amersfoortse wijk Kruiskamp dat er een open houding lijkt te zijn voor iedereen, maar dat er in de praktijk impliciete waarden worden gehanteerd waar buitenstaanders zich op moeten aanpassen.…”