Effect of REDD+ projects on local livelihood assets in Keo Seima and Oddar Meanchey, Cambodia

Abstract

Climate-change mitigation projects are expected to improve local livelihoods in targeted areas. Several REDDþ projects aimed at reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation, conserving and enhancing forest carbon stocks, and sustainably managing forests have been implemented in Cambodia but few studies have examined the effects on local livelihoods before and during project implementation. Our study applies a sustainable livelihood framework to assess the livelihood assets of local communities in the Oddar Meanchey and Keo Seima REDDþ project sites in Cambodia before and during project implementation. Five capital assets, namely natural, physical, human, financial, and social capital, are assessed and scored on a 1-to-5 Likert scale. Data analysis collected through 252 interviews in Oddar Meanchey and Keo Seima reveals a slight increase in livelihood assets in both sites from project validation to implementation. Generally, the mean scores for local livelihood assets increased from 2.81 AE 0.07 (AEis followed by the standard error) and 2.66 AE 0.06 to 3.07 AE 0.09 and 3.06 AE 0.08 in Oddar Meanchey and Keo Seima, respectively. Nevertheless, natural capital assets sharply declined from 3.50 and 3.32 to 2.09 and 2.25, respectively. Respondents mainly blamed illegal logging for the decline, suggesting that strict patrolling and enforcement must be implemented. Furthermore, the scarcity of carbon-credit buyers and the projects' inability to generate carbon-based revenues has led to dissatisfaction among local communities, inducing avoidable illegal activities in pursuit of short-term benefits. A financial mechanism to ensure sufficient and sustained financial support regardless of carbon-market volatility is urgently needed.

A systematic review of mangrove restoration studies in Southeast Asia: Challenges and opportunities for the United Nation’s Decade on Ecosystem Restoration

“…For one, the perceived social benefits (e.g., increased food and income) from restored mangroves, in general, and from carbon credits, in particular, may take time before the communities can realize it. While waiting for the tangible benefits, the communities have the tendency to resort to illegal activities (e.g., mangrove cutting) in pursuit of immediate and short-term economic gains (see for example Ken et al, 2020). Long-term growth and recovery of mangrove forests should be given more emphasis rather than the hype on carbon offsets (Wernick and Kauppi, 2022).…”

A Review of Global Policy Mechanisms Designed for Tropical Forests Conservation and Climate Risks Management

“…REDD+ is proposed as one of the interventions under the Paris Agreement that can bridge tropical forests conservation and climate risks management strategies through result-based payment (Plugge et al, 2013). A study by Ken et al (2020) establishes that implementation of REDD+ projects in Cambodia increased the physical, human, financial and social local livelihood assets with an average impact factor of 0.33. However, the natural livelihood assets declined by an average impact factor of 1.24, mainly because of illegal logging.…”

Elegibilidad de áreas para proyectos forestales en la región de Córdoba, Colombia

“…En otro orden de ideas, el comercio de emisiones de carbono se ha propuesto como un instrumento de política basado en el mercado para reducir los gases de efecto invernadero [GEI] emisiones (principalmente CO2) al menor costo posible (Ken et al, 2020;Sapkota and White, 2020). Desde los mercado de la Unión Europea [UE] lanzó el Plan comercial [EU ETS] el 1 de enero de 2005 para cumplir con el compromiso de una reducción del 8% en las emisiones de GEI para 2012 en comparación con 1990 propuesto en el Protocolo de Kyoto (European Commission, 2003).…”

“…El planeta tierra en los últimos años ha sufrido grandes afectaciones ambientales, producto de las prácticas de la desforestación y degradación de los bosques que amenazan de manera directa el medio y la supervivencia de todos los seres vivos (Ken et al, 2020;Li, Ngniatedema and Chen, 2017;Kaenzig and Wüstenhagen, 2010). A esto también, se suman los altos niveles de desarrollo de las empresas y la carrera por modernizar, automatizar distintos procesos, haciendo uso de materiales y productos que contamina el ambiente (Rajput, Bhagat and Chopra, 2020;Fuentes-Doria, Toscano-Hernandez and Sepulveda-Vargas, 2019) Algunos de los contaminantes vinculados al deterioro del medio, es la emisión del dióxido de carbono (en adelante CO2), gas que desfavorece la capacidad de la atmosfera para atrapar la energía infrarroja, afectando el clima y las condiciones medio ambientales (Rus et al, 2018).…”