Effectiveness of an edutainment video teaching standard precautions – a randomized controlled evaluation study

Abstract

Background Standard precautions are essential to prevent pathogen transmission and nosocomial infections. We assessed learning effect (primary outcome) and satisfaction (secondary outcome) of watching a 5-min humorous “edutainment (=education and entertainment) video” on Standard Precautions compared to reading a written standard operating procedure (SOP) or receiving no intervention. Methods This randomized controlled trial was executed at the University Hospital Zurich, Switzerland, a tertiary care centre with a state-of-the-art infection prevention programme. Healthcare providers (HCPs) of different medical departments were 1:1:1 randomized to watching the edutainment video (video group), reading the SOP (SOP group), or no study-specific intervention (no-intervention group). Online questionnaires included a knowledge assessment about Standard Precautions at time point (TP) 1 immediately after intervention, TP2 after 1 month, and TP3 after 3 months. Information about HCPs’ satisfaction with the learning method was collected. Variables were assessed within and between groups using the appropriate non-parametric tests. Predictors for knowledge of Standard Precautions were assessed by uni- and multivariable linear regression. Results Overall, 363 predominantly female (78.2%) HCPs were included. At TP 1 and TP3, the video group scored better on the knowledge assessment against both the SOP and the no-intervention group (TP1 p < .001 and 0.001, TP3 p = 0.036 and 0.048). In the multivariable analysis, being member of the video group was an independent predictor for better knowledge scores. The video was rated higher than the SOP regarding satisfaction with learning experience, and video group participants more frequently indicated they would recommend their learning method to colleagues. Conclusions Watching an edutainment video proved to be more effective to improve knowledge about Standard Precautions compared to reading an SOP or no intervention. Satisfaction with the learning method was superior in the video group, suggesting higher potential for future uptake. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (10.1186/s13756-019-0531-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

How does innovative technology impact nursing in infectious diseases and infection control? A scoping review

“…To improve knowledge on HAIs prevention, two studies considered e‐learning as a time‐effective approach. Additionally, e‐learning based on expert experience and an edutainment video is likely to be more effective to improve knowledge than the classic method (Labeau et al., 2016 ; Wolfensberger et al., 2019 ).…”

Compliance with standard precautions in inpatient healthcare settings in the Czech Republic: a cross-sectional survey

“…One of the ways to increase the knowledge of standard hygiene measures is also the use of educational videos. It has been shown that educating health professionals through an educational video is more effective for improving the knowledge of standard precautions than learning by reading (23). Standardized precautions and hygiene regulations are the most important measures to prevent and control infections, to reduce the transmission of microorganisms to patients or healthcare providers (24).…”

Low Adherence To Hand Hygiene: Analysis Of The Impact Factors In Critical Sectors Of A Hospital

“…Recent studies have shown that the use of training in this modality, based only on the transmission of knowledge and not protagonism of the participants, had little impact on adherence to Standard Precautions and HH. 19,20 Thus, WHO recommends that health institutions invest in multimodal strategies to improve HH with dynamic educational actions, based on permanent health education and multimodal strategy to improve HH in order to foster learning in the work environment through link between theory and practice. 11 In addition, dynamic methods that promote the interaction between professionals through wheels and talk, workshops and demonstration of HH practice have been more effective in increasing adherence to HH.…”