Effects of commitment-based governance on the relationship between formal control and PPP projects performance: mediating and moderating

Abstract

PurposeThis study aims to investigate the dual effects of commitment-based governance on the relationship between formal control and public–private partnership (PPP) project performance. Formal control and relationship governance are two primary forms of inter-organizational governance that affect project performance. However, little is known about the interplay between formal control and commitment and its effect on PPP projects. More specifically, previous studies have failed to distinguish the function routes of relationship governance resulting from different types of formal control (process and outcome control).Design/methodology/approachThis study adopts a questionnaire survey to empirically investigate the mechanism that commitment-based governance influences the relationship between formal control and PPP performance. After collecting data from public and private sector professionals involved in 101 Chinese PPP projects, the theoretical framework proposed in this paper is verified by the empirical results of the hierarchical multiple regression analysis.FindingsThe results show that process control has an inverted U-shaped effect and outcome control has a significant positive influence on PPP project performance. Furthermore, commitment moderates the effect of formal control on PPP project performance by increasing the relevance of outcome control and mediates the inverted U-shaped relationship between process control and PPP project performance.Practical implicationsManagers should recognize that process control is a double-edged sword and prevent the overuse of process control. Managers should direct their attention toward efforts to improve the commitment, which allows for the effectiveness of outcome control strategies. Additionally, this study new measurement method for relationship governance suggests that managers should be aware of the difference in parties' perceptions of the relationship.Originality/valueThis study allows for a comprehensive understanding of the relationship governance-control nexus from a commitment perspective. The authors bring into light the dual role of commitment-based governance in the relationship between the two types of formal control and PPP project performance. Moreover, the new approach to measure relationship governance offers valuable insight into the measurement of variables about individual's perception.

The impact of cross-organizational private relationships on cooperative behavior in construction projects: evidence from Chinese construction industry

“…Trust serves as an implicit moral constraint, which can reduces opportunistic behavior among contractors during cooperation (Wang et al, 2019). From a social psychology perspective, commitment has positive effect on cooperation and provides an implicit contract for future cooperative behavior (Iyer and Jha, 2005;Li et al, 2024). Meanwhile, relationship norms emphasize the establishment of mutually beneficial cooperative relationships among project participants, facilitating the smooth exchange of information and resources (Wang et al, 2019).…”

“…, 2019). From a social psychology perspective, commitment has positive effect on cooperation and provides an implicit contract for future cooperative behavior (Iyer and Jha, 2005; Li et al. , 2024).…”