Effects of frame rate and image resolution on pulse rate measured using multiple camera imaging photoplethysmography

Abstract

Non-contact, imaging photoplethysmography uses cameras to facilitate measurements including pulse rate, pulse rate variability, respiration rate, and blood perfusion by measuring characteristic changes in light absorption at the skin's surface resulting from changes in blood volume in the superficial microvasculature. Several factors may affect the accuracy of the physiological measurement including imager frame rate, resolution, compression, lighting conditions, image background, participant skin tone, and participant motion. Before this method can gain wider use outside basic research settings, its constraints and capabilities must be well understood. Recently, we presented a novel approach utilizing a synchronized, nine-camera, semicircular array backed by measurement of an electrocardiogram and fingertip reflectance photoplethysmogram. Twenty-five individuals participated in six, five-minute, controlled head motion artifact trials in front of a black and dynamic color backdrop. Increasing the input channel space for blind source separation using the camera array was effective in mitigating error from head motion artifact. Herein we present the effects of lower frame rates at 60 and 30 (reduced from 120) frames per second and reduced image resolution at 329x246 pixels (one-quarter of the original 658x492 pixel resolution) using bilinear and zero-order downsampling. This is the first time these factors have been examined for a multiple imager array and align well with previous findings utilizing a single imager. Examining windowed pulse rates, there is little observable difference in mean absolute error or error distributions resulting from reduced frame rates or image resolution, thus lowering requirements for systems measuring pulse rate over sufficient length time windows.

Can Wearable Devices Accurately Measure Heart Rate Variability? A Systematic Review

“…As wearable healthcare technology and the research of light propagation in human tissues are progressing, it is expected that PPG applications will expand. For instance, there is a growing interest to remotely depict PPG through imaging such as contactless video-photoplethysmography (vPPG) 50 or imaging PPG (IPPG) 51 .…”

Photoplethysmography Revisited: From Contact to Noncontact, From Point to Imaging

“…Briefly, they developed a multi-imager array, which includes nine synchronized digital cameras coupling with 10 full-spectrum bulbs [105], [107]. Through increasing the dimensionality of the imager channel space prior to the blind source separation, they achieved satisfactory HR readings compared to the motionless fingertip references, showing a promising trend for the development and transition of IPPG for everyday use.…”

iPhys: An Open Non-Contact Imaging-Based Physiological Measurement Toolbox

“…When choosing the compression and file format for storing iPPG video datasets this must be considered. The resolution and framerate [3] of a video has an expected and less significant impact on the performance of iPPG algorithms. Super resolution [18] can be used to reduce the error in heart rate estimates from low-resolution videos.…”