Effects of load estimation error on small-scale off-grid photovoltaic system design, cost and reliability

Abstract

The proliferation of off-grid photovoltaic (PV) systems is rapidly increasing in the least developed countries. The sizing of system componentsprimarily PV panels and batteries-is critically influenced by the expected daily load. However, accurately estimating incipient electrical load of rural consumers is fraught with challenges. Load estimation error is propagated through the design phase, potentially resulting in a system that is unduly expensive or fails to meet reliability targets. This article investigates the effects of daily load estimation error on system design, cost and reliability. Load and insolation data from seven off-grid systems in Malawi were collected. The systems were redesigned using three different intuitive design approaches considering different levels of load estimation error, ranging from ± 90% of the actual measured load. The cost of each design is estimated from in-country prices. The reliability of each design is determined from an hourly simulation using the measured data. The results show that PV array and battery sizing scale proportionately with load estimation error and that the cost of load over-estimation is approximately US$1.92 to US$6.02 per watthour, whereas underestimation can precipitously degrade reliability. A cost-versus-reliability analysis shows that for the Malawi systems, on average 46% of the PV and battery costs are used to improve the simulated hourly

ESCoBox: A Set of Tools for Mini-Grid Sustainability in the Developing World

“…Two studies, employing techniques similar to the authors' Monte Carlo simulations at [13] that are the basis of the decision support tool, have further demonstrated the need for systematic load planning. Louie and Dauenhauer [31] show how errors in load forecasting leading to overload conditions have a severe effect on reliability, while Mandelli et al [32] seek to mitigate the impact of load profile uncertainty in a system design method. A key point we have sought to keep in mind in this project is that however sound the initial design no mini-grid system can remain static in operation-the customer base and commercial pressures on the operator will evolve continuously and ideally the system capacity will need to expand as the customers prosper.…”

Sustainability evaluation of community-based, solar photovoltaic projects in Malawi

“…Capital expenditure (Cap) includes the panel costs which were calculated as $1.555/W p and battery costs as $0.168/Wh. This was determined by a linear regression from a field survey of 20 local company quotes of each taken in 2015 [50]. Additional capital costs such as labor, installation, inverter, charge controller, and other costs are calculated as a proportion, 24.2%, of panel and battery costs.…”

Planning for Electrification: On- and Off-Grid Considerations in Sub-Saharan Africa

“…The mobile phone subscription rate in SSA is surprisingly high -estimated to be 76 subscriptions per 100 people . Mobile phones are extremely beneficial to villagers, allowing farmers to check market prices before selling, simplifying logistics, or enabling mobile payment (Louie and Dauenhauer 2016). Even in areas without reliable mobile service, mobile phones are popular as they can often be used as radios or to play music (Kemeny et al 2014).…”

“…The state-of-practice demand prediction for larger size systems like mini-grids is to utilise door-to-door surveys to gather information on actual and aspirational appliance ownership and usage, from which the demand is predicted. The predictions can be largely inaccurate (Louie and Dauenhauer 2016), which can lead to over-or under-designed systems. Over-designed grids are an inefficient use of capital, as money is wasted on excessively sized equipment, and the surplus energy cannot be sold elsewhere as can be done in an interconnected grid.…”

“…In many areas, kerosene has been the fuel of choice for evening lighting. However, kerosene lamps have low efficacy and are linked with negative health and safety outcomes (Energy Sector Management Assistance Program 2015; Louie and Dauenhauer 2016). Kerosene lamps are often used indoors, where they might spill, or come in contact with flammable materials.…”