“…Often, the transient signal is analyzed by assuming that it depends linearly upon either the transient electron ͑and lattice͒ temperature, 6,10 or the transient excess total electron energy, 11 or the transient electron occupation number. 12 However, such an assumption ͑referred to as the "linearity assumption" from hereon͒ is not self-consistent since transient reflectivity and transmission signals appear to have a different temporal shape, [13][14][15][16][17][18] and hence cannot be both proportional to the same function of time, e.g., the transient electron temperature. As has been known since the early optical thermomodulation studies of metals, 19 rigorous analysis instead requires the transient reflectivity and transmission to be properly calculated from the dependence of the complex dielectric function upon the electron occupation number.…”