Electronic but overly eclectic: Disciplined EHR data management is needed to automate MIPS reporting.

Abstract

e18074 Background: Physician reimbursement for care delivered to Medicare beneficiaries fundamentally changed with the 2015 MACRA legislation, requiring eligible clinicians to report quality measures in the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS). To determine whether structured data in electronic health records (EHRs) were adequate to report MIPS results, EHR data ingested by ASCO’s CancerLinQ (CLQ) was analyzed. Methods: Nineteen MIPS measures specified for medical oncology, including 8 shared by other specialties, were retrieved from qpp.cms.gov and systematically evaluated to determine data elements necessary to satisfy each measure. The existence of corresponding data fields and completion of these fields with clinical data was analyzed according to EHR implementation in de-identified and aggregated CLQ data. Results: Five clinician informaticists reviewed the 19 oncology MIPS measures, and identified a consensus list of 52 discrete EHR data elements (DEs) that would be needed. CLQ-processed data from 4 commercial EHR systems implemented at 47 CLQ practices found structured data fields for 84% (43 of 52) of the DE, but fewer than half (46%) of these fields were ever populated and only 32% (17 of 52) of DE were recorded for > 20% of cases. Only 3-5 of 19 MIPS measures could be reliably reported based on data element availability by most practices in this sample set. There were minimal differences between the EHRs ability to encode MIPS DE. Elements most likely to be encoded were those for registration (birthdate, gender), billing (diagnosis, meds), vital signs and smoking status, while those seldom or never encoded related to care plans (tobacco, alcohol, pain management). Other DE rarely encoded were patient events occurring outside the oncology practice (receipt/completion of consultations, dates of hospice enrollment and death), which would be dependent on data exchange between work units and practice entities or, more likely, re-entry by oncology practices. Conclusions: Only a minority of DE required to satisfy MIPS criteria are available as discrete data fields in current EHRs, limiting automated reporting efforts. Improved data quality and completeness is needed to satisfy mandated reporting.