Engineering biology in the face of uncertainty

Abstract

Combining engineering and biology surely must be a route to delivering solutions to the world's most pressing problems in depleting resources, energy and the environment. Engineers and biologists have long recognized the power in coupling their disciplines and have evolved a healthy variety of approaches to realizing technologies. Yet recently, there has been a movement to narrow the remit of engineering biology. Its definition as ‘the application of engineering principles to the design of biological systems' ought to encompass a broad church. However, the emphasis is firmly on construction ‘…of novel biological devices and systems from standardized artificial parts’ within cells. Thus, engineering biology has become synonymous with synthetic biology, despite the many longstanding technologies that use natural microbial communities. The focus on the nuts and bolts of synthetic organisms may be deflecting attention from the significant challenge of delivering solutions at scale, which cuts across all engineering biology, synthetic and natural. Understanding, let alone controlling, every component of an engineered system is an unrealistic goal. To realize workable solutions in a timely manner we must develop systematic ways of engineering biology in the face of the uncertainties that are inherent in biological systems and that arise through lack of knowledge.

Engineering biology and climate change mitigation: Policy considerations

“…At this early stage in the development of EngBio mitigation applications, it is too early to predict which technological pathways will have the greatest technical potential and political feasibility 51 . The fine-grained work of identifying the most promising applications, supporting their technological development, eliminating regulatory barriers, and crafting incentives for deployment will necessarily occur within national political communities and policy-making bodies.…”