Enhancing the Auditor's Report: To What Extent is There Support for the IAASB's Proposed Changes?

Abstract

SYNOPSIS This article outlines proposed reforms to auditor reporting currently being considered by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB), and other key national and transnational standard-setters and regulatory bodies. It adds to recent academic contributions on reforming the auditor's report by analyzing the 165 stakeholder responses to the IAASB's 2012 Invitation to Comment: Improving the Auditor's Report to determine levels of support for the IAASB's proposed reforms, and the differences, if any, between the views of various respondents based on stakeholder groups (e.g., audit and assurance firms, users, preparers, regulators, etc.) and regional classifications. Guided by insights from communication theory, our results show the levels of stakeholder support for the IAASB's proposed reforms addressing auditors' expectations, information, and communication gaps are mixed. The strongest overall support was for enhanced auditor reporting on other information attached to, or intended to be read with, the financial statements, and the least supported initiative was including additional information in the auditor's report about the auditor's judgments and processes. While overall there is generally consensus across both stakeholder groups and regions concerning the various questions investigated, we highlight where statistically significant differences between groups do exist. Notably, North American respondents were less likely to support a number of the IAASB's proposed reforms than their counterparts from other regions. Data Availability: The data used in this study are referred to on the IAASB's website.

Addressing Information Needs to Reduce the Audit Expectation Gap: Evidence from Dutch Bankers, Audited Companies and Auditors

“…RQ1a is, therefore, answered positively; bankers do find additional information regarding the entity in the auditor's report of higher importance than managers and auditors. The positive attitude of users of financial statements to include information about the audited entity is consistent with Simnett and Huggins () observation on the responses by stakeholder groups on the IAASB's auditor reporting consultation process and the studies by Turner et al . () and Vanstraelen et al .…”

Optimistic tone and audit fees: Some Australian evidence

“…The motivation for this study originates from three sources. First, auditors' considerations of information accompanying audited financial statements has gained increasing attention in recent times (Simnett & Huggins, ). This trend is consistent with financial statement users' needs for qualitative corporate disclosures as an important source of information (Lang & Lundholm, ; Lawrence, ).…”

The relevance of financial information and contents of the new audit report for lending decisions of commercial banks

“…IAASB exposure draft of ISA 700 released in 2013 initiated many researches about the perception of auditors and other users of new proposed changes. In these studies respondents have supported the IAASB's proposed reforms addressing the expectations, information and communication gaps (Simnett & Huggins, 2014). Recent studies indicate that participants give attention to the supplementary information presented in the auditor's reports and that the matters mentioned in the report affect the participants' information acquisition in a way that users paid higher attention to the information mentioned in the key audit matters in auditor's report.…”