Ethical judgments in the sharing economy: When consumers misbehave, providers complain

Abstract

The complex triadic relationships among consumers, providers, and platforms in the sharing economy have led to increasing conflicts in the interactions between the actors involved, especially when it comes to unethical behavior, such as rule breaking by consumers. This paper examines consumer misbehavior from the perspective of their peers, i.e., service providers. In two studies (an experiment and a survey, combined N = 452), we observe a significant positive effect of ethical climate and a significant negative effect of trust in consumers on providers' strictness of ethical judgments of consumer misbehavior and through this on negative word of mouth. Further, the survey results show that the relationship between the strictness of ethical judgments and negative word of mouth is only significant for providers with low or medium levels of trust in the platform. The results highlight the importance of regulating consumer misbehavior in the sharing economy.

Consumo colaborativo en hostales de La Candelaria (Bogotá, Colombia)

“…Estos cambios que trae consigo la economía colaborativa, no necesariamente siempre son buenos, si se tiene en cuenta que se pueden generar efectos no deseables en lo social, lo ambiental y lo económico. En ocasiones se co-destruye valor en el ecosistema económico del alojamiento compartido (Buhalis, Andreu y Gnoth, 2020), ya que como lo muestran Culiberg et al (2023), cuando los consumidores incumplen reglas y tiene comportamientos poco éticos se afecta su relación con proveedores y plataformas, dando lugar a conflictos entre las partes.…”