Evaluating the acceptability of ethical recommendations in industry 4.0: an ethics by design approach

Abstract

In this paper we present the methodology we used in a European Horizon 2020 project in order to evaluate the implementation of the ethical component of the project. The project is a three-year collaboration between a university partner and industrial and tech partners, which aims to research the integration of AI services in heavy industry work settings. An AI ethics approach developed for the project has involved embedded ethical analysis of work contexts and design solutions and the generation of specific and evolving ethical recommendations for partners. We have performed an ongoing evaluation and monitoring of the implementation of recommendations. We describe the quantitative results of these implementations: overall, broken down by category, and broken down by category and responsible project partner (anonymized). In parallel, we discuss the results in light of our approach and offer insights for future research into the ground level application of ethical recommendations for AI in heavy industry.