Examining the magnitude and perception of summertime overheating in London care homes

Abstract

This paper brings together objective and subjective data on indoor temperature and thermal comfort to examine the magnitude and perception of summertime overheating in two London-based care homes occupying modern and older buildings. Continuous monitoring of indoor and outdoor temperature, relative humidity and CO2 levels was conducted in summer 2019 along with thermal comfort surveys and semi-structured interviews with older residents and staff of the care settings. Indoor temperatures were found to be high (>30°C) with bedroom temperatures often higher at night than daytime across both care settings. Limited opening due to window restrictors constrained night-time ventilation. Overheating was prevalent with four out of the five monitored bedrooms failing all four overheating metrics investigated. While 35–42% of staff responses perceived indoor temperatures to be uncomfortably hot, only 13–19% of resident responses were found to do so, indicating that elderly residents tend to be relatively insensitive to heat, leaving them open to overheating without realising it. Residents and staff in the modern care setting were less satisfied with their thermal conditions. As hybrid buildings, care settings need to keep both residents and staff comfortable and healthy during hot weather through night-time ventilation, management of heating and supportive institutional practices. Practical application: Care home designs have focused on keeping residents warm through the winter, neglecting the risks of summertime overheating. Care homes are hybrid buildings serving as living spaces for vulnerable older residents and offices/workspaces for staff. Providing comfort to both groups during periods of hot weather is challenging. Opportunities for ventilation are limited by Health & Safety regulations that mandate up to 10 cm maximum window openings and institutional practices that result in windows routinely kept closed, particularly at night. Utilising natural and where possible cross-ventilation should be considered along with external shading. Heating should be managed to avoid unwanted heat gains in the summer.

Monitoring summertime indoor overheating and pollutant risks and natural ventilation patterns of seniors in public housing

“…Yet, even in the newer LEED-certified building on site C where smoking was absent and residents reported operating the A/C, less than 50% of indoor HI and PM 2.5 measurements lie within the acceptable zone, which indicates insufficient protection of seniors from overheating and air pollutants. This finding aligns with the results of a monitoring study by Gupta et al, 93 who found severe summertime overheating in a modern 2013-built care home in London, UK, and with the results of Ade and Rehm, 57 who found significant signs of overheating in a green-rated building for retirees in Auckland, NZ during the two warmest months of the year. Substantial variations in indoor thermal and air quality conditions are further revealed by comparing apartments within each site, some of which are counterintuitive.…”

Supporting dementia care by monitoring indoor environmental quality in a nursing home

“…Existing studies have pointed out the overheating risk in care facilities during summertime, 58 which also remains in the wintertime. Six factors could influence thermal comfort in a particular scenario: metabolic rate, clothing insulation, air temperature, radiant temperature, airspeed and humidity.…”