Plants defend themselves against pathogens using either resistance, measured as the host’s ability to limit pathogen multiplication, or tolerance, measured as the host’s ability to reduce the negative effects of infection. Tolerance is a promising trait for crop breeding, but its genetic basis has rarely been studied and remains poorly understood. Here, we reveal the genetic basis of leaf tolerance to the fungal pathogenZymoseptoria triticithat causes the globally important septoria tritici blotch disease on wheat. Leaf tolerance toZ. triticiis a quantitative trait that was recently discovered in wheat by using automated image analyses that quantified the symptomatic leaf area and counted the number of pycnidia found on the same leaf. A genome-wide association study including both tolerance and resistance to STB found a strong negative genetic correlation between these traits, indicative of a trade-off. We identified four chromosome intervals associated with tolerance and a separate chromosome interval associated with resistance. Within these intervals, we identified candidate genes, including wall-associated kinases similar toStb6, the first cloned STB resistance gene. A trade-off between tolerance and resistance would hinder breeding simultaneously for both traits, but our findings suggest a way forward using marker-assisted breeding. We expect that the methods described here can be used to characterize tolerance to other fungal diseases that produce visible fruiting bodies, such as speckled leaf blotch on barley, potentially unveiling conserved tolerance mechanisms shared among plant species.