Exploring the potential of metabarcoding to disentangle macroinvertebrate community dynamics in intermittent streams

Abstract

Taxonomic sufficiency represents the level of taxonomic detail needed to detect ecological patterns to a level that match the requirement of a study. Most bioassessments apply the taxonomic sufficiency concept and assign specimens to the family or genus level given time constraints and the difficulty to correctly identify species. This holds particularly true for stream invertebrates because small and morphologically similar larvae are hard to distinguish. Low taxonomic resolution may hinder detecting true community dynamics, which thus leads to incorrect inferences about community assembly processes. DNA metabarcoding is a new, affordable and cost-effective tool for the identification of multiple species from bulk samples of organisms. As it provides high taxonomic resolution, it can be used to compare results obtained from different identification levels. Measuring the effect of taxonomic resolution on the detection of community dynamics is especially interesting in extreme ecosystems like intermittent streams to test if species at intermittent sites are subsets of those from perennial sources or if independently recruiting taxa exist. Here we aimed to compare the performance of morphological identification and metabarcoding to detect macroinvertebrate community dynamics in the Trebbia River (Italy). Macroinvertebrates were collected from four perennial and two intermittent sites two months after flow resumption and before the next dry phase. The identification level ranged from family to haplotype. Metabarcoding and morphological identifications found similar alpha diversity patterns when looking at family and mixed taxonomic levels. Increasing taxonomic resolution with metabarcoding revealed a strong partitioning of beta diversity in nestedness and turnover components. At flow resumption, beta diversity at intermittent sites was dominated by nestedness when family-level information was employed, while turnover was evidenced as the most important component when using Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs) or haplotypes. The increased taxonomic resolution with metabarcoding allowed us to detect species adapted to deal with intermittency, like the chironomid Cricotopus bicinctus and the ephemeropteran Cloeon dipterum. Our study thus shows that family and mixed taxonomic level are not sufficient to detect all aspects of macroinvertebrate community dynamics. High taxonomic resolution is especially important for intermittent streams where accurate information about species-specific habitat preference is needed to interpret diversity patterns induced by drying and the nestedness/turnover components of beta diversity are of interest to understand community assembly processes.

Pioneer annual vegetation of gravel-bed rivers: first insights on environmental drivers from three Apennine streams

“…This represents an urgent issue due to the drastic reduction in summer base-flow rates observed in several temperate regions, including the Po plain in the last decades (Datry et al, 2014;Laini et al, 2020;Messager et al, 2021). In the presence of prolonged summer drought events, an increasing homogenization in terms of species could be expected to the advantage of ruderal plants.…”

Implications of taxonomic and numerical resolution on DNA metabarcoding-based inference of benthic macroinvertebrate responses to river restoration

“…This advantage was previously demonstrated in macroinvertebrate taxa studies (e.g., Baird & Hajibabaei, 2012;Emilson et al, 2017;Serrana et al, 2019). The false positive detection between the two methods could be due to the lack of reference sequences and misclassifications in the database or primer bias effects (Carew et al, 2017;Laini et al, 2020).…”

“…Although previous studies have assessed the influence of taxonomic resolution on DNA metabarcodingbased assessments (e.g., Laini et al, 2020), the evaluation of different taxonomic level for identifying taxa without losing significant ecological detail is still largely unexplored. Furthermore, the numerical resolution of data, i.e., qualitative -presence/absence vs. quantitative -relative or absolute abundance, may influence the outcome of ecological analyses (Mueller, Pander & Geist, 2013;Heino, 2014;Pires et al, 2021).…”

The first DNA barcode library of Chironomidae from the Tibetan Plateau with an evaluation of the status of the public databases

“…In metabarcoding studies, it is crucial to determine taxonomic resolution and identity threshold for molecular identification (Laini et al, 2020 ). Taxonomy can be assigned using either a fixed and high identity value where only fine resolution assignments (i.e., genus or species) are obtained or a multilevel assignment approach where assignments at multiple taxonomic levels are conducted using different identity value thresholds (Alberdi et al, 2018 ).…”