Understanding how the brain transforms motor plans into the appropriate pattern of muscle activity is a central question in motor control. Whereas some neurophysiological studies in non-human primates have shown the presence of early recruitment of motor units, other studies have reported recruitment of motor units to occur just prior to movement initiation. To address this issue in humans, and test whether early recruitment is task dependent, we studied anterior deltoid muscle activity using high density surface EMG during visually guided delayed and immediate movement tasks while subjects used either hand or isometric cursor movements. Whereas spatially specific delay period activity was present for hand movements, it was absent for isometric movements. Nonetheless, muscle activity was correlated with the time it took to initiate movements in both the task conditions. Further, we used an accumulator framework to assess initiation of movements in different task contexts. Interestingly, we found consistent but different parameters of the accumulator model to play an important role in initiating hand and cursor movements: whereas the growth rate of muscle activity was an important determinant of reaction times in delayed and immediate hand movement tasks, the onset of muscle activity recruitment played a consistent and important role in determining the reaction time for initiating cursor movements during the delayed and immediate tasks. Overall, our results reveal an unexpected heterogeneity of early recruitment as seen with high density surface EMG that may relate to the differential extent of planning engendered during actual hand movements versus isometric movements.