Field Research and Numerical CFD Analysis of Humpback Whale-Inspired Shortboard Fins

Abstract

Compared to other Olympic sports, little research exists on competitive shortboard surfing—especially research comparing field and numerical data. In this paper, GPS sensors with 9-axis motion sensors were used to collect data on nearly 2000 surfed waves. Data were collected from four surfers of differing skill levels, ranging from intermediate/advanced (Level 6) to top-ranked professional (Level 9). The results revealed a positive correlation between surfer skill level and roll/pitch/yaw rates during a cutback. Some surfers used two different fin types: a standard commercial fin (C), and a 3D-printed, humpback whale-inspired fin (RW). Statistically significant cutback performance improvements were seen when surfers used the RW fin. Because of the skill level differences suggested by the field data, dynamic computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis was performed to simulate cutback maneuvers at three different rotation rates (roll/pitch/yaw). Sustained resultant forces relative to the rider direction were lower for RW fins during the turn, suggesting a less-skilled surfer could generate faster and more powerful turns using RW fins. Field results also confirmed that a skill Level 8 surfer performed closer to skill Level 9 when using RW fins, but not control fins. Surfers experienced more stability using RW fins, and CFD results confirmed RW’s ability to dampen the effects of turbulent flow.

Numerical Investigation of the Hydrodynamic Characteristics of 3-Fin Surfboard Configurations

“…The higher C D these templates report after stall is also an indication of more intense drops in velocity after stall. Shormann et al [18] also discuss the potential board control and recovery benefits of fins with gradual stall behaviour and turbulence damping between the side and centre fins. This observation was also investigated by El-Atm et al [2] when comparing different fin configurations.…”

“…It is important to note this study looks at only the yaw motion of a turning surfboard, whereas real-world turning involves a combination of yaw, pitch, and roll [18]. During turns, it is also possible for the fins to not be fully immersed in water, which would affect the forces involved.…”

Computational fluid dynamics performance evaluation of grooved fins for surfboards

“…The same principle can be applied to the lift and drag experienced by fins in surfboards. Several researchers have studied the hydrodynamic performance of three-and four-fin configurations using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) [3,[5][6][7][8][9][10]. It has been shown that the maximum lift for threefin configurations occurred at smaller angle of attached compared to four-fin configurations [6].…”