Fighting Poverty and Protecting the Urban Environment: The Refuse Collectors of Rio De Janeiro, Brazil

Abstract

SUMMARY This paper reviews and documents a unique approach to poverty reduction targeting a segment of urban poor in the city of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: the collectors of recyclable materials discarded by urban residences and businesses, along with their refuse. The approach is unique for Brazil because it combines assorted policy objectives at different governmental levels, two socially/security valued, two environmentally valued and one economically valued. The paper specifically seeks to (a) determine the current profile of collectors, both social and economic; (b) assess the current state of play of the dwindling collectors cooperatives programme, including perceptions of its performance by different stakeholders; (c) describe the current practices and players in the collection of recyclables, with its associated implications; (d) reconstruct the role of key players with a focus on the operational policies and administration of the programme by municipal departments; (e) assess the current priority among social and environmental objectives of the waste collection programme of the municipal government; (f) draw conclusions and recommendations on policies and administration for such programmes, to improve the social outcome for the collectors while still achieving the associated environmental objectives; and (g) draw some comparisons with other Latin American countries that have engaged in similar programmes. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Managing the Principal Agent Problem in Bolsa Familia: A look at contextual factors that affect the quality of implementation

“…Incentives in this case would refer to a direct accountability relationship between provider and recipient, a clear policy framework, or potentially a financial incentive to provide good-quality services. Intermittent and inconsistent policy may also be a factor, as seen in municipal support for refuse collectors in Brazil (see Pinto et al, 2012). In this case, the agent (recycling refuse collector) finds it difficult to operate and build capacity without a consistent policy framework and incentive from the municipality.…”

The Value of Five Cents: Mismatched Meaning Making at a Bottle and Can Redemption Center

“…Fleshing out redemption work as an occupation engaged in by men and women across socioeconomic status, race, immigration status, and age offers a complementary picture of the profession painted by Gowan (2010). While earning a living through redemption and waste picking has been studied extensively in the Global South (e.g., Gutberlet, Seixas, and Carolsfeld 2007; Medina 2008; Pinto and Carmon 2012), there is not an extensive literature on this population in more developed countries like the United States.…”