Flexible bronchoscopic intubation through a supraglottic airway device: An evaluation of consultant anaesthetist performance

Abstract

BackgroundFew clinical studies investigate technical skill performance in experienced clinicians.MethodsWe undertook a prospective observational study evaluating procedural skill competence in consultant anaesthetists who performed flexible bronchoscopic intubation (FBI) under continuous ventilation through a second‐generation supraglottic airway device (SAD). Airway management was recorded on video and performance evaluated independently by three external assessors. We included 100 adult patients undergoing airway management by 25 anaesthetist specialists, each performing four intubations.We used an Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills‐inspired global rating scale as primary outcome. Further, we assessed the overall pass rate (proportion of cases where the average of assessors' evaluation for every domain scored ≥3); the progression in the global rating scale score; time to intubation; self‐reported procedural confidence; and pass rate from the first to the fourth airway procedure.ResultsOverall median global rating scale score was 29.7 (interquartile range 26.0–32.7 [range 16.7–37.7]. At least one global rating scale domain was deemed ‘not competent’ (one or more domains in the evaluation was scored <3) in 30% of cases of airway management, thus the pass rate was 70% (95% CI 60%–78%). After adjusting for multiple testing, we found a statistically significant difference between the first and fourth case of airway management regarding time to intubation (p = .006), but no difference in global rating scale score (p = .018); self‐reported confidence before the procedure (p = .014); or pass rate (p = .109).ConclusionConsultant anaesthetists had a median global rating scale score of 29.7 when using a SAD as conduit for FBI. However, despite reporting high procedural confidence, at least one global rating scale domain was deemed ‘not competent’ in 30% of cases, which indicates a clear potential for improvement of skill competence among professionals.