This study examines the effect of day-of-the-week, month-of-the-year, and turn-of-the-month anomalies on NFT coins (Stacks, Tezos, and Decentraland) and Bitcoin over the period 2019–2023 by employing the generalized autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity (GARCH) model. Based on the day-of-the-week anomaly results, Bitcoin has lower returns on Thursdays and Fridays, and Stacks has lower returns on Wednesdays. The remaining coins do not exhibit that anomaly. According to the month-of-the-year effect results, all evaluated coins generated abnormal returns in January. Moreover, positive returns were also reported in February for Tezos, Decentraland, and Bitcoin. Additionally, Bitcoin experienced positive returns in March as well. Furthermore, besides January, Stacks had significantly positive returns in April and May. Finally, the results of the turn-of-the-month anomaly suggest that only Stacks has statistically significant and positive returns on the last day of the month and the next three days. The remaining cryptocurrencies do not have such an anomaly. Overall, the findings of this study suggest the existence of calendar anomalies in the cryptocurrency market that contradict the assumptions of market efficiency. By using these outcomes, investors may develop trading strategies for their portfolio selection; hence, by taking advantage of the market, they could earn unusual profits.