Framing ‘Green Jobs’ Discourse: Analysis of Popular Usage

Abstract

The emerging concept of Green Jobs has yet to be clearly defined. This study uses critical discourse analysis and framing theory to analyse the meaning of Green Jobs claims, and their representation and transformation. Based on an analysis of print media from 1999 to 2009 and supporting policy documents, five predominant frames were identified in Green Jobs discourse: Environment–Economy Bridge, Green Entrepreneurship, Nascent Industry Creation, Internal Industry Transformation, and Structural Adjustment. Coverage of Green Jobs discourse has sharply increased since 2008. Although the term remains loosely defined and is employed in multiple ways, it is predominantly used as a strategic link between the recession and climate change policy. The fractured framing used in Green Jobs discourse hinders its uptake as a meaningful concept informing job creation, greening of industry, and sustainable development policy. Media, policymakers and advocacy groups should clarify the underlying definition when using the term. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and ERP Environment.

What Does the Media Mean by ‘Sustainability’ or ‘Sustainable Development’? an Empirical Analysis of Sustainability Terminology in German Newspapers Over Two Decades

“…This makes the sustainability discourse a grand public debate. The debates about specific concepts such as corporate social responsibility (Ihlen and Roper, ) or green jobs (Kouri and Clarke, ) illustrate how different framings and interpretations of these concepts compete over supremacy in discourse, each underpinned by specific interests, actors and ideologies. Journalists, equipped with a critical attitude and sensorium for the political and power issues in societal controversies, still consider it as a key function of their profession to provide orientation and interpretation on such grand debates (Ward, ).…”

Civil society perspectives on green jobs in sustainable energy: The case of European Malta

“…Conceptual clarification resurfaces as a recommendation for advocacy groups, policymakers and media in Kouri's and Clarke's (2014) analysis of the framing of green jobs' discourse. The researchers identify discourse fractures that hinder the uptake of green jobs discourse 'as a meaningful concept informing job creation, greening of industry, and sustainable development policy' (217).…”

From learning to fragile governance: Regional economic development in rural Peru

“…Effective governance entails collective action and leadership. The existence of shared values, vision, and commitment can motivate actors across a region to collaborate (Horlings and Padt, 2011). Rural areas tend to be socially heterogeneous, creating a particular need for collective leadership to coordinate across multiple networks embedded in place (Collinge and Gibney, 2010;Horlings and Padt, 2011).…”

“…The existence of shared values, vision, and commitment can motivate actors across a region to collaborate (Horlings and Padt, 2011). Rural areas tend to be socially heterogeneous, creating a particular need for collective leadership to coordinate across multiple networks embedded in place (Collinge and Gibney, 2010;Horlings and Padt, 2011). Shared leadership structures should help actors in political networks to make decisions (Karlsen and Larrea, 2012) e yet, the way power is institutionalized can shape leadership practices, creating a need for more awareness of the siting of leadership (Hidle and Normann, 2012).…”

“…For example, in the reservoir case, local families organized (horizontal) joint action, articulated a clear vision for the future, and gained the attention of higher levels of government. Although the specific institutional arrangements will vary by place, the development of this vision into a new narrative for the area is key to motivating collective action and leadership across this area, given the challenge of its social and geographic diversity (Horlings and Padt, 2011).…”