From Bedside to Bench and Back Again: Research Issues in Animal Models of Human Disease

Abstract

To improve outcomes for patients with many serious clinical problems, multifactorial research approaches by nurse scientists, including the use of animal models, are necessary. Animal models serve as analogies for clinical problems seen in humans and must meet certain criteria, including validity and reliability, to be useful in moving research efforts forward. This article describes research considerations in the development of rodent models. As the standard of diabetes care evolves to emphasize intensive insulin therapy, rates of severe hypoglycemia are increasing among patients with type 1 and type 2 diabetes mellitus. A consequence of this change in clinical practice is an increase in rates of two hypoglycemia-related diabetes complications: hypoglycemia-associated autonomic failure (HAAF) and resulting hypoglycemia unawareness. Work on an animal model of HAAF is in an early developmental stage, with several labs reporting different approaches to model this complication of type 1 diabetes mellitus. This emerging model serves as an example illustrating how evaluation of validity and reliability is critically important at each stage of developing and testing animal models to support inquiry into human disease.

Red Bull® energy drink increases consumption of higher concentrations of alcohol

“…Here, we report the first characterization of operant energy drink self‐administration, as well as its effects on alcohol self‐administration. Given that this method has a very high predictive validity in humans (Tkacs & Thompson ), the feasibility of operant energy drink and mixed alcohol/energy drink self‐administration constitutes a further advance that likely will help us understand the impact of these beverages on human health. Furthermore, in order to mimic more precisely human energy drink consumption, we used one of the most consumed energy drink worldwide, i.e.…”

Animal models of the cancer anorexia–cachexia syndrome

“…A powerful animal model also needs to be reliable, i.e., reproducible within the same circumstances at different times, and between various laboratories. This is often an issue in basic research [61]. -Study design is as important as the choice of animal model [17].…”

Animal studies in restless legs syndrome

“…The quality of an animal model is characterized by its reliability, and by its validity. 1,2 There are three concepts of validity that can be distinguished: face validity, predictive validity, and construct/etiological validity. In short, face validity is high if the model exhibits a behavioral or biological syndrome that meets typical criteria used to define the syndrome in humans.…”

“…To model restless legs syndrome (RLS) in animals, two steps are necessary: (1) The essential constituents of a (behavioral) animal phenotype of RLS have to be defined. (2) Knowledge and hypotheses on the etiology of RLS have to be applied to animals, to see if an expected animal phenotype can be observed.…”