Games between stakeholders and the payment for ecological services: evidence from the Wuxijiang River reservoir area in China

Abstract

A gambling or “game” phenomenon can be observed in the complex relationship between sources and receptors of ecological compensation among multiple stakeholders. This paper investigates the problem of gambling to determine payment amounts, and details a method to estimate the ecological compensation amount related to water resources in the Wuxijiang River reservoir area in China. Public statistics and first-hand data obtained from a field investigation were used as data sources. Estimation of the source and receptor amount of ecological compensation relevant to the water resource being investigated was achieved using the contingent valuation method (CVM). The ecological compensation object and its benefit and gambling for the Wuxijiang River water source area are also analyzed in this paper. According to the results of a CVM survey, the ecological compensation standard for the Wuxijiang River was determined by the CVM, and the amount of compensation was estimated. Fifteen blocks downstream of the Wuxijiang River and 12 blocks in the water source area were used as samples to administer a survey that estimated the willingness to pay (WTP) and the willingness to accept (WTA) the ecological compensation of Wuxijiang River for both nonparametric and parametric estimation. Finally, the theoretical value of the ecological compensation amount was estimated. Without taking other factors into account, the WTP of residents in the Wuxi River water source was 297.48 yuan per year, while the WTAs were 3864.48 yuan per year. The theoretical standard of ecological compensation is 2294.39–2993.81 yuan per year. Under the parameter estimation of other factors, the WTP of residents in the Wuxi River water source area was 528.72 yuan per year, while the WTA was 1514.04 yuan per year. The theoretical standard of ecological compensation is 4076.25–5434.99 yuan per year. The main factors influencing the WTP ecological compensation in the Wuxi River basin are annual income and age. The main factors affecting WTA are gender and attention to the environment, age, marital status, local birth, and location in the main village.

Water-Related Payment Schemes for Forest Ecosystem Services in Selected Southeast European (SEE) Countries

“…There is still a lack of understanding that the provision of these ES depends on the management of different resource (forests) [58] and requires additional funding, especially to private forest owners to ensure continuity of ES provision [16]. The lack of markets on which these ES can be traded is another reason why regulatory agencies need to intervene to create these markets [39,109,110]. Examples from analysed countries illustrate those interventions that are more or less successful in financing the provision of water-related forest ES especially through internationally funded projects that are disseminated on international or regional level.…”

Gospodarka Surowcami Mineralnymi - Mineral Resources Management

“…The criteria for ecological compensation based on a life cycle approach may be beneficial in providing a holistic view for stakeholders through all stages of production (Chen et al 2020). A game can be observed in the complex relationship between sources and recipients of ecological compensation among multiple stakeholders (Shu 2018).…”

Public willingness to pay watershed eco-compensation in China’s Taihu basin: A case study

“…They also analyzed the correlation between residents' socio-economic characteristics and their willingness to pay (WTP). Shu (2018) adopted the CVM to calculate the WTP of residents at different times. Yao et al (2019) investigated residents' WTP for water quality changes in a coastal aquatic ecological area.…”