Gamification in Rehabilitation of Patients With Musculoskeletal Diseases of the Shoulder: Scoping Review

Abstract

Background Gamification has become increasingly important both in research and in practice. Particularly in long-term care processes, such as rehabilitation, playful concepts are gaining in importance to increase motivation and adherence. In addition to neurological diseases, this also affects the treatment of patients with musculoskeletal diseases such as shoulder disorders. Although it would be important to assist patients during more than one rehabilitation phase, it is hypothesized that existing systems only support a single phase. It is also unclear which game design elements are currently used in this context and how they are combined to achieve optimal positive effects on motivation. Objective This scoping review aims to identify and analyze information and communication technologies that use game design elements to support the rehabilitation processes of patients with musculoskeletal diseases of the shoulder. The state of the art with regard to fields of application, game design elements, and motivation concepts will be determined. Methods We conducted a scoping review to identify relevant application systems. The search was performed in 3 literature databases: PubMed, IEEE Xplore, and Scopus. Following the PICO (population, intervention, comparison, outcome) framework, keywords and Medical Subject Headings for shoulder, rehabilitation, and gamification were derived to define a suitable search term. Two independent reviewers, a physical therapist and a medical informatician, completed the search as specified by the search strategy. There was no restriction on year of publication. Data synthesis was done by deductive-inductive coding based on qualitative content analysis. Results A total of 1994 articles were screened; 31 articles in English, published between 2006 and 2019, were included. Within, 27 application systems that support patients with musculoskeletal diseases of the shoulder in exercising, usually at home but also in inpatient or outpatient rehabilitation clinics, were described. Only 2 application systems carried out monitoring of adherence. Almost all were based on in-house developed software. The most frequently used game components were points, tasks, and avatars. More complex game components, such as collections and teams, were rarely used. When selecting game components, patient-specific characteristics, such as age and gender, were only considered in 2 application systems. Most were described as motivating, though an evaluation of motivational effects was usually not conducted. Conclusions There are only a few application systems supporting patients with musculoskeletal diseases of the shoulder in rehabilitation by using game design elements. Almost all application systems are exergames for supporting self-exercising. Application systems for multiple rehabilitation phases seem to be nonexistent. It is also evident that only a few complex game design elements are used. Patient-specific characteristic are generally neglected when selecting and implementing game components. Consequently, a holistic approach to enhance adherence to rehabilitation is required supporting patients during the entire rehabilitation process by providing motivational game design elements based on patient-specific characteristics.

Effectiveness of physical therapy given by telerehabilitation on pain and disability of individuals with shoulder pain: A systematic review

“…Randomized controlled trials delivering physical therapy care by telerehabilitation were included. The experimental group received telerehabilitation, which was considered as home-based exercises delivered through mobile applications, web-based instruments, exergames, 24 and videoconferencing. 25 Patient and provider interaction through telerehabilitation can be either synchronous (real-time rehabilitation) or asynchronous (delay between information being sent and received).…”

Technologies used to facilitate remote rehabilitation of adults with deconditioning, musculoskeletal conditions, stroke, or traumatic brain injury: an umbrella review

“…The field of healthcare technologies is vast and growing. It encompasses communication tools that allow remote consultations, 10,11 smart objects 12,13 and wearable devices [14][15][16] that can measure physical and physiological variables, technologies (including immersive and non-immersive virtual reality [VR] and augmented reality [AR]) that allow gamification of rehabilitation activities, [17][18][19] assistive and adaptive technologies, 20,21 and web-or mobile-based tools (including apps) that permit self-management and recording and sharing of information and patient-reported outcomes. 22,23 Some technologies are nascent and others are more established.…”

A multicenter randomized controlled trial comparing gamification with remote monitoring against standard rehabilitation for patients after arthroscopic shoulder surgery

“…The use of a Microsoft Kinect in rehabilitation for conditions including stroke, neurorehabilitation and frozen shoulder is well published in the literature 8,14,21,30 . In a recent metaanalysis Steiner et al 36 concluded that there are limited applications designed for rehabilitation of the shoulder. They found that those available commercially failed to deliver programs tailored to the multiple phases of rehabilitation.…”