Gender Differences in the State of Volitional Regulation among Various Ethnic Groups of the Russian Federation and the CIS

Abstract

The hypothesis about the relationship between masculinity of national culture and the severity of gender differences in the state of volitional regulation among its representatives is tested. Men and women were compared among representatives of masculine (Kabardin, Ossetian, Armenians, Tatars, Bashkirs, Tajiks) and feminine (Russians, Ukrainians, Belarusians, Komi, Mari, Koreans, Tuvans, Jews) ethnic groups. In total, 1453 people aged 18 to 30 years participated in the study. To diagnose the state of volitional regulation of the respondents, the following methods were used: “Action-control scale” by Yu. Kuhl, “Questionnaire for revealing the expression of self-control in the emotional sphere, activity and behavior”, self-appraisals of volitional qualities. It is shown that in masculine cultures, men and women significantly differ in terms of the “Action-control scale”, the severity of emotional, behavioral and social self-control, as well as self-assessments of volitional qualities, while in feminine cultures there are practically no differences. Men demonstrate qualities associated with the implementation of intentions in action, and women demonstrate qualities associated with the organization of their activities in accordance with the requirements of society.

From intentions to action: An integrative review of action control theory and research

“…The AOD-scale first appeared in German and English (Kuhl, 1994). In subsequent years, the scale has been translated into at least 16 additional languages, including Bengali (Chatterjee et al, 2018), Chinese (Song et al, 2006), Croatian (Niemivirta et al, 2001), Dutch (Koole & Jostmann, 2004), Farsi (Calero et al, 2007), Finnish (Niemivirta et al, 2001), French (Bouzidi & Gendolla, 2022), Greek (Papantoniou et al, 2010), Indonesian (Elia et al, 2022), Japanese (Sakuma & Sato, 2008), Polish (Marszał-Wiśniewska, 2002), Portuguese (Branco et al, 2015), Russian (Shlyapnikov, 2020), Spanish (Calero et al, 2007), Turkish (Peker & Meşe, 2021), and Vietnamese (Helmke & Tuyet, 1999). Across these languages, the AOD-scale has consistently shown adequate internal consistency, with Cronbach's alphas typically ranging between .60 and .80.…”

Relationship between Volitional Regulation and Academic Achievements in University Students

“…Вместе выборке, можно предположить, что данный факт не оказал существенного влияния на результаты [16] . Методы исследования.…”