“…Although transgene-free methods have been developed using the clustered regularly interspersed short palindromic repeat/Cas system to improve perennial plants such as poplar, transgenic technologies are still powerful means to create new traits (Chen et al, 2018). Transgenic technology has been effectively used to produce poplar trees with a variety of useful traits, including herbicide resistance, biotic and abiotic tolerance, improved growth rate, higher nutrient use efficiency, and improved processing and end-use characteristics (Yang et al, 2009;Chang et al, 2018). Although many transgenic field trials have been carried out in the United States, China, and elsewhere, no transgenic trees have been commercially adopted to our knowledge (Li et al, 2016;Klocko et al, 2018).…”