Green colonialism in the Nordic context: Exploring Southern Saami representations of wind energy development

Abstract

This paper explores social representations of wind energy development within reindeer herding lands among the Indigenous Southern Saami living within Norwegian borders. For this matter, the paper combines Social Representations Theory (SRT) with the analytical framework of "circuits of dispossession and privilege" and decolonial approaches within community psychology. Data consisted of seven individual semi-structured openended interviews, three collective interviews, and observation in three lawsuits, public meetings, protest actions, and reindeer herding activities. The findings suggest that for the subjects in this study, the onset of wind power represents the renewal of historical processes of dispossession through accumulation and colonialism, enabled by harmful knowledge gaps in Norwegian society and institutions, contrasting Southern Saami's values of responsibility and ecological practices. The implication of these findings suggests an urgent need of rethinking renewable energy and including indigenous knowledge in climate change agendas.

“Time is our worst enemy:” Lived experiences and intercultural relations in the making of green aluminum

“…I focus on the Fosen Vind DA complex, which with over 1000 MW capacity, became Europe's largest onshore wind power complex, selling one-third of the energy to Norsk Hydro. Second, I focus on Øyfjellet Wind Park, Norway's largest independent wind farm when finished in 2021, owned by green-profile investment fund Aquila Capital, selling the total produced energy to Alcoa's aluminum plant in a neighboring town (Normann, 2021).…”

“…Several Saami participants reflected on differences between their own and other Indigenous peoples' experiences in places where direct violence occurs (Normann, 2021). This affected how "entitled" some seemed to feel to denounce their situation.…”

A Critical Framework to Develop Human-Centric Positive Energy Districts: Towards Justice, Inclusion, and Well-Being

“…Dunlap and Sullivan (2020) term this problem of distributive injustice as "accumulation-by-alienation" following Harvey's ( 2018) "accumulation-by-dispossession, " an abstraction of economic value from ecological systems (in this case land and energy resources) which alienate their symbolic relation to humans in order to quantify, commodify, and pay it off (see more in section Recognition Justice and People-Place Relations-Background in Peds and General Definition below). Other proposals from critical approaches to distributive justice have suggested the importance of acknowledging and better unveiling the global consequences of transnational energy projects and transitions through concepts such as energy or green colonialism (Batel and Devine-Wright, 2017;Normann, 2021). Both concepts draw attention to the global and historical injustices of energy generation and low-carbon technologies' production as they build upon structural, historical power asymmetries between the privileged and the dispossessed.…”

“…Attention must be paid to their concerns and values, and from a collective, local to global perspective, being considerate of social and ecological systems alike (Williams et al, 2014;Devine-Wright et al, 2019). This move from public participation to co-creation of PEDs not only requires the reexamination of mainstream knowledge, i.e., the decolonisation of energy (Lennon, 2017), but also the valuation of the lay public's energy conceptions through the reappraisal of indigenous and informal energy knowledge and practises (Normann, 2021). Future research should therefore further inquire into how this can be done outside structural, institutional constraints, and be based on bottom-up, community-led and aimed initiatives.…”

Inversión en energías eólicas en el Istmo de Tehuantepec –continuidad del colonialismo interno en las disputas territoriales

“…Esta lógica ha caracterizado por siglos a dichos proyectos. Actualmente se aplica a la agenda emergente de "crecimiento verde", donde los países buscan cumplir su objetivo de una economía baja en carbono (Normann 2020). Ello ha llevado a la "apropiación de tierras" a través de contratos injustos de arrendamiento de tierras, desarrollados bajo la retórica de la transición energética, el ambientalismo o el desarrollo sostenible (Sellwood & Valdivia 2018).…”