“…While there has been considerable interest in how earlier springs will affect annual C exchange through extended growing seasons, the directional effects of warm winters and early vernal transitions on C uptake and loss during the winter to spring transition have not been consistent across studies or vegetation types. Warm winters with early snowmelt often lead to longer growing seasons, which can enhance annual ecosystem C uptake (Danielewska et al, 2015;Delpierre et al, 2009;Galvagno et al, 2013;Keenan et al, 2014;Pulliainen et al, 2017;Wolf et al, 2016). However, the early loss of snow can also lead to photosynthesis occurring during unfavorable conditions (Winchell, Barnard, Monson, Burns, & Molotch, 2016), arrested physiological development of vegetation (Galvagno et al, 2013), or enhanced water stress (Arnone et al, 2008;Hu, Moore, Burns, & Monson, 2010) that offset C gains from the elongated growing season.…”