“…In particular, we discussed how the effective thermal conductivity (ETC) is influenced by the co-existence of ice, unfrozen water, and gas at frozen conditions. 29 It should be noted that the presence of different minerals (silt, clay, …) and their interaction with pore water influence not only the physical properties of the host sediment, but also the pore-scale distribution of the co-existing phases in pore space, 40 particularly at frozen conditions, where the unfrozen water content occupying small pores critically contributes to the heat tranfer. 29 The presence of hydrates adds further complexities, which is required to be well understood and accounted for in both lab- and field-scale studies; otherwise, the prediction of the thermal response of gas hydrate-bearing permafrost sediments would be erroneous.…”