“…Carbon isotope compositions of speleothems mainly reflect that of soil CO 2 overlying the cave (Genty & Massault, 1999;Genty et al, 2001;Li et al, 2011;Luo & Wang, 2009), which are influenced by biological processes such as plant root respiration, organic matter decomposition, and vegetation type (C4/C3 plant ratio) (Baker et al, 1997;Denniston et al, 2001;Dreybrodt, 1980;Duan et al, 2014Duan et al, , 2022Genty et al, 2003Genty et al, , 2006Hou et al, 2003;Jia et al, 2022;McDermott, 2004;Tan et al, 2013;Yin et al, 2017;Zhang et al, 2021;Zhao et al, 2020). Before 1588 AD, the δ 13 C of both stalagmites TS9701 and TS950 fluctuates between −11.7‰ and −7.7‰ (Figure 2), indicating that the vegetation overlying Shihua cave was predominantly C3 plants, as expected from speleothem δ 13 C values (−14‰ to −6‰) at such sites (Baker et al, 1997;Dreybrodt, 1980;McDermott, 2004).…”