How do people get engaged in civic participation? A case study of citizen activism in rebuilding Enning Road, Guangzhou

Abstract

This paper discusses how citizens become engaged in networks for civic engagement and what affects the initiation, continuity, and impact of an actual action. My case study of the citizens’ engagement in rebuilding Enning Road in Guangzhou found that virtual communities expanded people’s actual connections; Internet mobilization, owing to its broad connectedness, helped stimulate the initiation of public participation but the shared channel of this type of media lacked the power to start an actual action or maintain the momentum. The existing studies suggested that whether the public attention and discussion based on virtual communities could be transformed into sustainable and influential public participation in action depended upon whether the ‘issue’ had its own sustainability and also upon whether the mobilizing ‘agent’ was a rights-protecting group that shared similar interests. The case study reported in this paper, however, found that the off-line ‘liaison and mobilization mechanisms,’ as well as their closely related characteristics, were also significant factors. Connection and mobilization via interpersonal networks pushed virtual discussions into real actions and helped keep the actions going on, while the open space of the city expanded the actual social and policy influences for such actual civic engagement. The distinction of different liaisons from the mobilization mechanisms illustrated in this paper facilitates the explanation of the civic engagement in contemporary China from the ‘diachronic’ and ‘differentiated participation’ angles. The paper concludes that either interpersonal networking organizations being supplementary to the organization of social groups or the public space opened up by the city being supplementary to the closed nature of the structure of the political system itself is still quite limited in the civic engagement in China.

Heterogeneity of public participation in urban redevelopment in Chinese cities: Beijing versus Guangzhou

“…In 2009, the district government published the historic-cultural neighbourhood preservation and development plan, and hired a company to collect citizens' opinions on it. A total of 183 local households sent their objections to the district government one month later, but did not receive any substantive reply (Huang, 2013). Therefore, 220 local households handed petition letters to congress delegates during the annual Municipal People's Congress and Political Consultative Congress in April 2010 (Zhang and Li, 2016).…”

Cultural Policy Formation and State-Society Relations: Culture-led Urban Redevelopment of Enninglu in Guangzhou

“…However, these issues are less discussed in current research on state-society relations in China. Although many current studies on Enninglu have paid attention to issues such as public participation, policy adaptation, resilient governance, and state-society conflict (Huang 2017; Lee 2016; Tan and Altrock 2016; Yao et al 2021), most of them have not touched on cultural perspectives (e.g. cultural resistance and cultural policy responses), thus neglecting a more complex mechanism of state-society interaction mediated by culture.…”

From online to offline: The formation of collective action and its contributing factors: A case study of a food waste treatment facility location protest

“…(2011) proposed that whether or not cyber social networks affect social movements is determined by network leaders, users’ practices, and some elements in online and offline transformation. Huang (2013) pointed out that although a virtual community multiplies people’s ties with the real world, whether such ties can be transformed into persistent, public-engaged actions is closely related to the offline liaison and mobilization mechanism and its characteristics. Therefore, taking the online-formed social network as a given fact in studying other factors constitutes an inspiring research method.…”