“…Bibliometric analysis is widely applied in studies in various scientific fields. In economics, for example, bibliometric studies can be seen in Laila et al (2021) Other examples of studies with bibliometric methods include studies in the fields of accounting (Taqi et al, 2021;Rusydiana et al, 2020;Taqi et al, 2022;, finance As-salafiyah et al, 2022;Maulida, 2023), marketing (Rusydiana et al, 2023;Uula & Avedta, 2023;Putri & Irfany, 2023;Sari & Maysyaroh, 2022) Islamic economics (Marlina et al, 2021;Rusydiana, 2021;Sukmana et al, 2021;Nuraini, 2022), social finance (Nuraini, 2021;Niswah, 2022) to studies related to the halal industry (Izza, 2021;Nekha & Kartikawati, 2022;Rahardjo, 2023;. The most widely used tools in bibliometric studies are VosViewer (Uula & Ikhwan, 2022;Avedta, 2023;Sanrego & Taufiq, 2023;Riani, 2021) and the Biblioshiny-R application (Gunawan & Herman, 2022;Nuraini & Jazil, 2023;Puspita et al, 2023;Ikhwan, 2021).…”