Human behaviour, NPI and mobility reduction effects on COVID-19 transmission in different countries of the world

Abstract

Background The outbreak of Coronavirus disease, which originated in Wuhan, China in 2019, has affected the lives of billions of people globally. Throughout 2020, the reproduction number of COVID-19 was widely used by decision-makers to explain their strategies to control the pandemic. Methods In this work, we deduce and analyze both initial and effective reproduction numbers for 12 diverse world regions between February and December of 2020. We consider mobility reductions, mask wearing and compliance with masks, mask efficacy values alongside other non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) in each region to get further insights in how each of the above factored into each region’s SARS-COV-2 transmission dynamic. Results We quantify in each region the following reductions in the observed effective reproduction numbers of the pandemic: i) reduction due to decrease in mobility (as captured in Google mobility reports); ii) reduction due to mask wearing and mask compliance; iii) reduction due to other NPI’s, over and above the ones identified in i) and ii). Conclusion In most cases mobility reduction coming from nationwide lockdown measures has helped stave off the initial wave in countries who took these types of measures. Beyond the first waves, mask mandates and compliance, together with social-distancing measures (which we refer to as other NPI’s) have allowed some control of subsequent disease spread. The methodology we propose here is novel and can be applied to other respiratory diseases such as influenza or RSV.

Sources, diffusion and prediction in COVID-19 pandemic: lessons learned to face next health emergency

“…Another critical limitation of epidemiological models for COVID-19 forecasting is that they did not consider the behavioral change of people in the presence of a pandemic [117] . In fact, people with the fear to be infected and/or of die with a new infection, they adapt the behaviour to new situation taking provident actions to protect themselves and survive in uncertain environments [118] .…”

Diffusion and Prediction of Covid-19 Pandemic: Limits of Models and Strategies to Improve Outlook and Preparedness to Face Next Pandemics

“…Appropriate prediction models of infectious diseases, like COVID-19, should be age-dependent. Another critical limitation of epidemiological model applied for COVID-19 is the reductionism approach that did not consider the behavioral change of people in the presence of a pandemic (Mohammadi et al, 2022). In fact, many epidemiologic models do not consider that people, with the fear to be infected and/or of die with new infections, can adapt the behaviour to new situation taking provident actions to protect themselves and survive (Stangier et al, 2022).…”

Disposable Face-Mask Waste Management and Assessment Through Willingness to Pay and SWOT Framework in Post COVID-19 Pandemic

“…The COVID-19 pandemic period has made masks the main thing among the public that must be used in outdoor and indoor activities as a preventive measure to avoid the virus [20][21][22], as well as very strict regulations governing the use of community masks [23][24][25]. Indonesia had a percentage of 82% compliance with use in 2020, this is due to the policy to use masks when mobility is outside [26]. The use of masks is very significant, almost every day during a pandemic, causing high demand and demand for disposable masks.…”