Model systems have previously been developed in which herpes simplex virus (HSV) is retained in human fibroblasts in a nonreplicating state known as quiescence. The HSV type 1 (HSV-1) immediate-early (IE) protein ICP0, an important activator of gene expression, reactivates the quiescent genome and promotes the resumption of virus replication. Previous studies reported that infection with ICP0-null HSV-1 mutants fails to reactivate quiescent HSV, even when the mutant itself undergoes productive replication, leading to the hypothesis that quiescent genomes exist in a silent configuration in which they are shielded from trans-acting factors. I reinvestigated these findings, using HSV-1 mutants with lesions in the transcription activators VP16, ICP0, and ICP4 to establish quiescent infection at high efficiency. Superinfection with ICP0-null HSV-1 mutants at a low multiplicity of infection (MOI), so that individual plaques were formed, reactivated expression from the quiescent genome, demonstrating that the requirement for ICP0 is not absolute. The previously reported failure to observe reactivation by ICP0-null mutants was shown to be a consequence of either a low initial MOI or a high superinfecting MOI. Competition between viral genomes at the level of gene expression and virus replication, especially when ICP0 was absent, was demonstrated during reactivation and also during normal infection of human fibroblasts. The results show that the multiplicity-dependent phenotype of ICP0-null mutants limits the efficiency of reactivation at low MOIs and that competition between genomes occurs at high MOIs. The conclusion that quiescent HSV genomes are extensively silenced and intrinsically insensitive to trans-acting factors must be reevaluated.Infection with wild-type herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) usually results in productive virus replication and death of the host cell. Viral genes are expressed in a coordinated cascade characterized by three phases, immediate-early (IE), early, and late. IE genes are the first to be transcribed, and the IE proteins, particularly ICP4, ICP0, and ICP27, play crucial roles in the synthesis of early and late proteins. The ICP4 protein is essential for productive infection, stimulating early and late RNA synthesis through interactions with basal cellular transcription factors (7, 52). Protein ICP0 is not essential for virus replication, but infection in its absence is initiated inefficiently in many cell types (12,42,45,46). Human fibroblasts are particularly restrictive for replication of ICP0-null mutants, but in contrast, the human osteosarcoma line U2-OS is fully permissive (51). ICP0 is a ubiquitin E3 ligase, suggesting that it acts by stimulating proteolysis of strategic cellular targets (4, 15). The tegument protein VP16 strongly stimulates IE transcription shortly after entry of the virion into the host cell, providing a further level of gene regulation (6, 35). Virus mutants that specify nonfunctional VP16 are phenotypically similar to ICP0-null mutants, exhibiting a cell typ...