Human resource management interventions to improve health workers' performance in low and middle income countries: a realist review

Abstract

BackgroundImproving health workers' performance is vital for achieving the Millennium Development Goals. In the literature on human resource management (HRM) interventions to improve health workers' performance in Low and Middle Income Countries (LMIC), hardly any attention has been paid to the question how HRM interventions might bring about outcomes and in which contexts. Such information is, however, critical to assess the transferability of results. Our aim was to explore if realist review of published primary research provides better insight into the functioning of HRM interventions in LMIC.MethodologyA realist review not only asks whether an intervention has shown to be effective, but also through which mechanisms an intervention produces outcomes and which contextual factors appear to be of critical influence. Forty-eight published studies were reviewed.ResultsThe results show that HRM interventions can improve health workers' performance, but that different contexts produce different outcomes. Critical implementation aspects were involvement of local authorities, communities and management; adaptation to the local situation; and active involvement of local staff to identify and implement solutions to problems. Mechanisms that triggered change were increased knowledge and skills, feeling obliged to change and health workers' motivation. Mechanisms to contribute to motivation were health workers' awareness of local problems and staff empowerment, gaining acceptance of new information and creating a sense of belonging and respect. In addition, staff was motivated by visible improvements in quality of care and salary supplements. Only a limited variety of HRM interventions have been evaluated in the health sector in LMIC. Assumptions underlying HRM interventions are usually not made explicit, hampering our understanding of how HRM interventions work.ConclusionApplication of a realist perspective allows identifying which HRM interventions might improve performance, under which circumstances, and for which groups of health workers. To be better able to contribute to an understanding of how HRM interventions could improve health workers' performance, a combination of qualitative and quantitative research methods would be needed and the use of common indicators for evaluation and a common reporting format would be required.

Does therapeutic writing help people with long-term conditions? Systematic review, realist synthesis and economic considerations

“…Previous review teams have identified that the data necessary for conducting a high-quality realist synthesis is often not found in RCTs. However, as the included studies consisted of a broader range of study types and much larger numbers of studies than that found in Dieleman et al 148 and Kane et al 149 it was anticipated during the project that sufficient data would be available. To supplement the data within the studies included in the effectiveness review, two additional searches were undertaken: one to look for studies on facilitated TW and the other for studies of any type that reported on one or more of the included studies.…”

Eficiencia de los recursos humanos en salud: una aproximación a su análisis en México

“…Diversos países de América Latina, África y Asia ensayan nuevas formas gerenciales para remunerar al personal a fin de motivar el trabajo, aumentar la productividad, la calidad de la atención y promover el trabajo en equipo. 20 La eficiencia productiva considera como estrategia de Eficiencia y recursos humanos para la salud Artículo originAl medición el volumen de consultas generales generadas por médico, así como la relación entre el volumen de consultas generales y la disponibilidad de médicos por unidad de población. 21,22 A pesar de su relevancia para el cumplimiento de metas y objetivos de los sistemas de salud, los estudios que abordan la eficiencia en RH son escasos, 23 y los existentes no dimensionan sus hallazgos en un marco de eficiencia.…”

Commonly cited incentives in the community implementation of the emergency maternal and newborn care study in western Kenya

“…On the other hand, each community is unique and the challenges as well as opportunities it provides are thus community specific. Incentives are context specific 14 , and each community's background needs to be studied to identify and apply the acceptable ones for the given community. By exploring attitudes towards small incentives in a given context, it is possible to identify those that can be applicable and relevant.…”