“…The reported magnetic islands were observed from shock surface to the vicinity of the magnetopause, had a spatial size of a few tens of ion inertial length in the magnetosheath, and were characterized by a density depletion and magnetic field compression [Karimabadi et al, 2014, Figures 6, 9, and 13]. In spacecraft data, distinguishing between magnetic islands and flux ropes is not obvious (magnetic islands can indeed be seen as the 2-D version of 3-D flux ropes [e.g., Fu et al, 2015Fu et al, , 2016). In spacecraft data, distinguishing between magnetic islands and flux ropes is not obvious (magnetic islands can indeed be seen as the 2-D version of 3-D flux ropes [e.g., Fu et al, 2015Fu et al, , 2016).…”