Identifying Positive Adaptive Pathways in Low-Income Families in Singapore: Protocol for Sequential, Longitudinal Mixed-Methods Design

Abstract

Background This study aims to examine the adaptive process of children and mothers from multistressed low-income families in Singapore. It aims to bridge the knowledge gap left by existing poverty studies, which are predominately risk focused. Through a sequential longitudinal mixed-methods design, we will differentiate children and mothers who demonstrate varied social, developmental, and mental health trajectories of outcomes. Through utilizing the Latent Growth Curve Model (LGCM), we aim to detect the development and changes of the positive Family Agency and adaptive capacities of these families over time. The construct of Family Agency is underpinned by the theoretical guidance from the Social Relational Theory, which examines child agency, parent agency, relational agency, and the interactions among these members. It is hypothesized that positive Family Agency within low-income families may lead to better outcomes. The key research questions include whether the extent of positive Family Agency mediates the relationship among financial stress, resource utilization, home environment, and parental stress. Objective The study elucidates the Family Agency construct through interviews with mother-child dyads. It also aims to understand how financial stress and resources are differentially related to home environment, parent stress, and parent and child outcomes. Methods In phase 1, 60 mother-child dyads from families receiving government financial assistance and with children aged between 7 and 12 years will be recruited. In-depth interviews will be conducted separately with mothers and children. On the basis of 120 interviews, a measurement for the construct of Family Agency will be developed and will be pilot tested. In phase 2a, a longitudinal survey will be conducted over 3 time points from 800 mother-child dyads. The 3 waves of survey results will be analyzed by LGCM to identify the trajectories of adaptation pathways of these low-income families. In addition, 10 focus groups with up to 15 participants in each will be conducted to validate the LGCM results. Results This project is funded by the Social Science Research Thematic Grant (Singapore). The recruitment of 60 mother-child dyads has been achieved. Data collection will commence once the amendment to the protocol has been approved by the Institutional Review Board. Analysis of phase 1 data will be completed by the end of the first quarter of 2019, and the first set of results is expected to be submitted for publication by the second quarter of 2019. Phase 2 implementation will commence in the second quarter of 2019, and the project end date is in May 2021. Conclusions Findings from this study can potentially inform social policy and programs as it refines the under...

Why did COVID-19 not further harm the mental health of poor mothers? A mixed-method study on low-income families in Singapore

“…The research team amended the original protocol of the original study 29 introduced a basic semblance of psychological first aid (PFA). The moral obligation in studying a vulnerable population in the period which coincided with the unforeseen pandemic compelled the research team to implement a brief risk assessment to understand the stress and risk levels of all mothers as part of wave 3.…”

“…To address the research questions set out in this paper, a mixed method approach was used. The quantitative data stemmed from a larger study 29 where three waves of short-term longitudinal surveys were administered across Open access three time points to low-income mothers and children, with 6 months intervals, between 2019 and 2020. For this paper, only survey measurements on the mental health and resilience reported by low-income mothers were included, analysed and compared with examine the differences in outcomes.…”

“…Mother-child dyads were recruited for the larger study on low-income families in Singapore. 29 These families were receiving government financial aid at the time of recruitment or had previously received financial aid at one point during the 3 years before the time of recruitment. They also had a child between 7 and 12 years.…”

Trajectories of perceived economic hardship: Relations with mother’s and child’s mental health and the role of self-esteem

“…Mother–child dyads were recruited for a study on low-income families in Singapore (Goh et al, 2019 ). The study recruited mother–child dyads whose families 1) were receiving government financial aid at the time of recruitment or had previously received financial aid at one point during the three years before the time of recruitment; and 2) had a child between 7 and 12 years of age.…”

Hope in Low‐Income Families—A Study of Family Hardiness in Singapore

“…Five hundred and thirteen mother-child dyads from a study on low-income families in Singapore (Goh et al, 2019) were recruited for this study. Initially, close to 800 potential mother-child dyads were contacted for the study, but some potential participants did not participate in the study because they were uncontactable, busy, or managing an illness in the family.…”