Identifying the Critical Stakeholders for the Sustainable Development of Architectural Heritage of Tourism: From the Perspective of China

Wang, Ruiling; Guo, Liejin; Zhou, Jingjiao; Wang, Jianhui

doi:10.3390/su11061671

Cited by 35 publications

(24 citation statements)

References 45 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…The key to LWSM is to select an evaluation set. A Likert scale served as the evaluation set in many previous studies [50,51]. Hence, it was adopted here to measure the severity of each design barrier: 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 represent very weak, weak, medium, strong, and very strong, respectively [52].…”

Section: Measurement Of Barrier Strengthmentioning

confidence: 99%

Research on the Barrier Analysis and Strength Measurement of a Prefabricated Building Design

Yuan

Wang

et al. 2020

Sustainability

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

As a sustainable and cleaner type of facility, prefabricated buildings face more design barriers than traditional non-prefabricated buildings. Identifying and managing these barriers is key to improving the success rate of prefabricated building design. However, direct studies on these design barriers are extremely rare. The present study solved this problem by combining multiple methods, including grounded theory (GT), structured self-intersection matrix (SSIM), analytic network process (ANP), and the linear weighted sum method (LWSM). GT was adopted to identify the barriers to prefabricated building design and then SSIM was used to analyze the interactions among them. The eight design barriers were finally identified and classified into three clusters: technical barriers, economic barriers, and management barriers. A further analysis found that there is dependence and feedback among these clusters. The technical barrier cluster and management barrier cluster experience self-feedback. A network model based on ANP was next established to calculate the weights of the barrier elements and then this model was combined with LWSM to evaluate the overall design barrier strength of a project case. The results showed that architectural individualization has the greatest impact on prefabricated building design, followed by the collaborative issues among multiple units and professional designer issues. The overall design barrier strength of the project case was larger. Therefore, the first suggestion provided to the facility management sector is to establish a library for standard house types to achieve architectural design through multihouse combinations.Sustainability 2020, 12, 2994 2 of 16 construction [7], and off-site construction [8]. Whether emergency-driven or market-driven, prefabricated buildings are becoming increasingly popular. However, several barriers affecting the development of prefabricated buildings are often mentioned, including a higher total cost [9], impaired aesthetics [10], additional risks [11], a lack of professional expertise [12], and the absence of management experience [13]. Nevertheless, prefabricated buildings are still favored by the government of China due to their many advantages, including their faster construction speed [14], less required on-site labor [15], higher construction quality [16], sustainable development [17], and superior occupational health and safety [18]. With the development of prefabricated buildings, some new issues are beginning to emerge and become increasingly prominent, especially the design changes of prefabricated buildings. Bogenstatter noted that the design stage determines up to 80% of operational costs, as well as the environment impacts [19,20]. Hence, design changes can waste a great deal of time and money and even affect the quality of buildings. Overcoming this issue remains a troubling prospect for industry insiders and researchers.Design changes are common not just for ordinary buildings but also for prefabricated buildings. However, the design of a p...

show abstract

Section: Measurement Of Barrier Strengthmentioning

confidence: 99%

Research on the Barrier Analysis and Strength Measurement of a Prefabricated Building Design

Yuan

Wang

et al. 2020

Sustainability

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…In response to this, certain measures need to be taken to reverse the local public's perceptions, and sustainable cultural heritage management practices are human-centered [11], which can enhance the connection between the local public and the environmental space. Previous research on cultural heritage has been about local community participation in heritage management, factors which are partially involved in preservation practice [12][13][14]; however, in these research pieces, the opinions of local residents were not taken into full consideration. In the present research, the local community takes the roles of the owner and user in order to participate in the cultural heritage preservation process for sustainability through the landscape narrative.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

On the Sustainability of Local Cultural Heritage Based on the Landscape Narrative: A Case Study of Historic Site of Qing Yan Yuan, China

2021

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

As a feature of local cultural heritage, historical garden sites should not only focus on landscape sightseeing, but should also champion the sustainability of cultural heritage and promote the local community’s wellbeing. This article uses the landscape narrative method to explore how the local public, with both professional and non-professional backgrounds, manages the cultural heritage and enhances its sustainability. Qing Yan Yuan is a historical garden site in Huai’an, Jiangsu Province, China, and constitutes the research area of this study. This article firstly conducts in-depth interviews with local residents with non-professional backgrounds; then, it collects relevant information from professionals, such as introductions, comments, news, periodicals, etc.; finally, it adopts the content analysis method to decode, summarize and sort out accordingly. Through the analysis of landscape narrative data, this paper found that three cultural heritage value strategies are used by the public: (1) origin landscape narrative; (2) functional landscape narrative; (3) meaningful landscape narrative. The origin landscape narrative is the expression of a cultural heritage value of “past presentation”; the functional landscape narrative is a cultural heritage value of “place identity”; the meaningful landscape narrative shows a cultural heritage value of “future education”; all these together constitute the local public subjective conception of the sustainability of cultural heritage.

show abstract

“…As stated by Convencido et al (2019), considerations and analysis of stakeholders’ perspectives can enhance and develop development in a heritage property by balancing changes and conservation. In the context of heritage and urbanization, some of the stakeholders are: ‘national and local government; heritage property management body, local community, urban and rural developers; heritage conservation advocates, business and private sectors such as tourism; academic and expert group; media, architectural and engineering firms; and visitors and other people who appreciates heritage’ (Wang et al, 2019). Their perspectives must be documented, analysed and considered for conceptualizing programmes and projects for heritage properties, which will enhance the significance of sustainable development and conservation.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Bridge over Troubled Water: Explicating the Perspectives of the Stakeholders on the Urbanization of Heritage Properties—The Case of Intramuros and Filipino–Chinese Friendship Bridge

Duarte

Garcia

Lejano

et al. 2020

Journal of Heritage Management

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This qualitative case study article explicated the perspectives of the stakeholders regarding the urbanization of heritage properties, specifically the old, walled area of Intramuros in the city of Manila with respect to the construction of the Filipino-Chinese Friendship Bridge (or the bridge). This study begins with a documentation analysis involving the collection of researches related to the subject and in-depth interviews with the different stakeholders, specifically the national and local government, the private sectors and the host community in Intramuros and Binondo. The case study approach is incorporated in the study to discern the issues arising from the subject site, while a thematic analysis is used as the most suitable technique to analyse the findings. The outcomes reveal the different viewpoints of the stakeholders concerning the matters in constructing the Filipino–Chinese Friendship Bridge between Intramuros and Binondo. In this context, authorities such as the government and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) should establish regulations that seek to protect and conserve the different heritage properties, as well as balance the demands for rapid urbanization. Due to the urban development, the integrity and significance of heritage properties are being compromised, which may result in the degradation of the local properties’ identity and culture.

show abstract

Identifying the Critical Stakeholders for the Sustainable Development of Architectural Heritage of Tourism: From the Perspective of China

Cited by 35 publications

References 45 publications

Research on the Barrier Analysis and Strength Measurement of a Prefabricated Building Design

Research on the Barrier Analysis and Strength Measurement of a Prefabricated Building Design

On the Sustainability of Local Cultural Heritage Based on the Landscape Narrative: A Case Study of Historic Site of Qing Yan Yuan, China

Bridge over Troubled Water: Explicating the Perspectives of the Stakeholders on the Urbanization of Heritage Properties—The Case of Intramuros and Filipino–Chinese Friendship Bridge

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About