The idiopathic inflammatory myopathies (IIMs) are chronic disorders characterized by inflammation in skeletal muscle but also in other organs such as the skin, lungs, joints, gastrointestinal tract, and heart. The effect of immunosuppressive treatment varies between individual patients and between organ manifestations within the same individual. Many patients respond poorly to first-line treatment with glucocorticoids and other immunosuppressive agents such as methotrexate or azathioprine, with symptoms persisting in the muscles, skin, and lungs, leading to refractory disease. Management of refractory IIM is a clinical challenge, and a systematic approach is proposed to better understand the lack of treatment response, in order to guide disease management. The first step in the management of refractory IIM is to recognize whether remaining symptoms are caused by persistent inflammation in the affected tissue or whether the symptoms may be attributable to damage preceding inflammation. Thus, a second diagnostic examination is recommended. Second, in particular for patients with remaining muscle weakness, it is important to ascertain whether the diagnosis of myositis is correct or whether another underlying muscle disorder could explain the symptoms. Third, with confirmation of remaining inflammation in the tissues, a strategy to change treatment needs to be undertaken. Few controlled trials are available to guide our treatment strategies. Furthermore, different subgroups of patients may benefit from different therapies, and different organ manifestations may respond to different therapies. In this context, subgrouping of patients with IIM based on autoantibody profile may be helpful, as there are emerging data from open studies and case series to support the notion of a varying treatment response in different autoantibody-defined subgroups of IIM patients.
Clinical challengeThe index patient, a 38-year-old woman, presented with weakness of the proximal leg muscles, elevated creatine kinase (CK) levels (5 times the upper limit of normal), signs of myopathy on electromyogram, and atrophy of the gluteus muscles on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). A biopsy sample from the thigh muscle showed some fiber size variation and internal nuclei, but otherwise normal histopathology. She was diagnosed as having polymyositis (PM). Despite having received treatment with high-dose glucocorticoids in combination with azathioprine followed by cyclosporine (methotrexate treatment was excluded due to pregnancy planning) and despite a routine of regular physical exercise, the patient's muscle weakness progressed and she developed atrophy of her hamstring muscles-a refractory myopathy.