Implementing a National Electronic Referral Program: Qualitative Study

Abstract

BackgroundElectronic referrals or e-referrals can be defined as the electronic transmission of patient data and clinical requests between health service providers. National electronic referral systems have proved challenging to implement due to problems of fit between the technical systems proposed and the existing sociotechnical systems. In seeming contradiction to a sociotechnical approach, the Irish Health Service Executive initiated an incremental implementation of a National Electronic Referral Programme (NERP), with step 1 including only the technical capability for general practitioners to submit electronic referral requests to hospital outpatient departments. The technology component of the program was specified, but any changes required to embed that technology in the existing sociotechnical system were not specified.ObjectiveThis study aimed to theoretically frame the lessons learned from the NERP step 1 on the design and implementation of a national health information technology program.MethodsA case study design was employed, using qualitative interviews with key stakeholders of the NERP step 1 (N=41). A theory-driven thematic analysis of the interview data was conducted, using Barker et al’s Framework for Going to Full Scale.ResultsThe NERP step 1 was broadly welcomed by key stakeholders as the first step in the implementation of electronic referrals—delivering improvements in the speed, completeness of demographic information, and legibility and traceability of referral requests. National leadership and digitalized health records in general practice were critical enabling factors. Inhibiting factors included policy uncertainty about the future organizational structures within which electronic referrals would be implemented; the need to establish a central referral office consistent with these organizational structures; outstanding interoperability issues between the electronic referral solution and hospital patient administration systems; and an anticipated need to develop specialist referral templates for some specialties. A lack of specification of the sociotechnical elements of the NERP step 1 inhibited the necessary testing and refinement of the change package used to implement the program.ConclusionsThe key strengths of the NERP step 1 are patient safety benefits. The NERP was progressed beyond the pilot stage despite limited resources and outstanding interoperability issues. In addition, a new electronic health unit in Ireland (eHealth Ireland) gained credibility in delivering national health information technology programs. Limitations of the program are its poor integration in the wider policy and quality improvement agenda of the Health Service Executive. The lack of specification of the sociotechnical elements of the program created challenges in communicating the program scope to key stakeholders and restricted the ability of program managers and implementers to test and refine the change package. This study concludes that while the sociotechnical elements of a national health information...

Synthesis, Biological Activity, and Molecular Modelling Studies of Naphthoquinone Derivatives as Promising Anticancer Candidates Targeting COX-2

“…For compounds 9 and 12 , diffraction data were collected at low temperature (220.0(1) K) on an automatic four-circle diffractometer single-crystal X-ray diffractometer Rigaku, XtaLAB Synergy, Dualflex, HyPix using Cu K α monochromatic radiation (λ = 1.54184 Å). The crystal structures were solved by direct methods with the ShelXT [ 52 ] structure solution program using intrinsic phasing and refined with the SHELXL refinement package [ 53 ]. All calculations were performed with the help of Olex2 software [ 54 ].…”

A review of distributed ledger technologies application in medical systems interoperability

“…Organizational Interoperability: The highest level of interoperability takes into account governance, policy, legal, and social factors (Macedo & Isaías, 2013;McGovern et al, 2018). It requires coordinating the plans, policies, and practices of numerous healthcare organizations and entities in order to enable safe, effective, and timely data use and communication.…”

Scaling up a National Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation Referral Service for adult patients in acute severe respiratory failure at the time of a pandemic

“…Implementation of systems, similar to the one proposed, are reported to take weeks or longer. [3][4][5][6] Each referring ICU in the country was notified of the change and was encouraged to refer patients with SRF for ECMO via the new referral system.…”